 |
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 Next > Jump to: Bottom Last Post
Abacab2112 Male, 13-17, Midwest US
   386 Posts
|
Tuesday, February 03, 2009 3:14:13 PM Well, Altaru, Rome never became a police state per se, but they decayed from a well-established republic like the United States to mob rule and finally to oligarchy under the Caesars and those who proceeded them. It's no police state, but with the technology of their day, it's as close as it gets.It all happened because the people forgot that their liberties were important. The nation became paranoid, established an unsustainable empire, made "funny money" out of worthless metals, and the people became dependent on the government for public funding. Sound familiar? |
|
Altaru Male, 13-17, Eastern US
   699 Posts
|
Monday, February 02, 2009 6:12:12 PM "Ignorance is shining through brightly in those statements. Apparently history isn't one of your "gifted" subjects."Oh? Show me an example of a well-established country that just all of a sudden became a police state. Let's see... Cuba and Russia both became police states after a revolutionary war, most of the middle east has ALWAYS been dictatorships and absolute control... When the people are set in their ways, you can't just take them over. Not without throwing their whole world into chaos first to give a reason for taking over. And the problem with that is, in the US, there are people who are actually ACTIVE in the effort to prevent just that from happening. Unfortunately, you sitting here on IAB wasting your time with a pointless arguement doesn't tell me that you're one of them... |
|
sixclaws13 Male, 18-29, Midwest US
   2308 Posts
|
Monday, February 02, 2009 3:35:55 PM "if this country was going to become a police state, we'd already be one.... a police state isn't made after a country is well established and the people are set in their ways. Ignorance is shining through brightly in those statements. Apparently history isn't one of your "gifted" subjects. Also, I was put in the gifted program at my school in fourth grade and stayed there for the rest of my education. Top score on all standardized tests and the ACT in my class. And you know what? It doesn't mean sh*t. I'd advise you to get over yourself now because in the real world no one cares about your IQ and you can't barter your way out of any situation using your test scores. I give that advice in honest sincerity and am abandoning this thread. |
|
Altaru Male, 13-17, Eastern US
   699 Posts
|
Monday, February 02, 2009 3:27:17 PM Of course, that's not to say the same revolutionaries wouldn't proceed to set up their own police state afterwards. After all, according to Sixclaws and the others, power corrupts, right? |
|
Altaru Male, 13-17, Eastern US
   699 Posts
|
Monday, February 02, 2009 3:26:58 PM I was against his comment that "he's never met anyone who said they were smart, and was."As for political and ethical wisdom, age STILL doesn't count for much, because as it is, many of the situations we're facing we've faced in the past, and the solutions we used back then didn't work. We need NEW thinkers, not people who believe the same old bullsh*t. On topic with the actual subject this arguement started with, if this country was going to become a police state, we'd already be one. There were many points in history where the government could have completely taken control, and taken away all of our freedoms. But they didn't. And they won't. Because a police state isn't made after a country is well established and the people are set in their ways. The people would launch a revolution, and in this country especially, the people would win. |
|
Abacab2112 Male, 13-17, Midwest US
   386 Posts
|
Monday, February 02, 2009 3:01:26 PM Altaru, when it comes to politics, ethics, history, etc., it is far more important to be wise than to be smart.As a 16-year-old, I'll argue a point I believe in for one of two purposes: 1) The other person may refute my argument successfully and I gain a new paradigm, am shown superior logic or am taught new information. 2) I am 100% sure I'm right. Option 2 doesn't happen very often because as a 16-year-old, I know that I have had far less world experience than my older contemporaries. Your IQ and academic skills are impressive, but they only indicate your intellectual potential, not your actual knowledge or wisdom. So from one kid to another: please don't use that kind of information in an argument. Actually refute their points and win on relevant information or concede and learn. Either option is good. |
|
Altaru Male, 13-17, Eastern US
   699 Posts
|
Monday, February 02, 2009 2:25:35 PM "I have never met someone who said, "I'm so smart" and had it been true."A) Quite likely because "smart" people tend to avoid the word, especially saying it in that manner. B) Classified as gifted since the age of 7 in the state of Ohio in the area's of Math, Science, Reading, and Writing, with a genius IQ. You just did. |
|
sixclaws13 Male, 18-29, Midwest US
   2308 Posts
|
Monday, February 02, 2009 1:55:15 PM "in my case at least, seeing as how I'm more intelligent and more mature than most fully grown adults"Ha ha, you also seem to have an ego problem. I have never met someone who said, "I'm so smart" and had it been true. |
|
Altaru Male, 13-17, Eastern US
   699 Posts
|
Monday, February 02, 2009 1:33:13 PM Not only does age say VERY little about a persons mental capacity, personality, or just about any other trait commonly associated with it (in my case at least, seeing as how I'm more intelligent and more mature than most fully grown adults), but...Angsty? Real world? I'm not the paranoid f*cking moron who thinks the government's going to take over every aspect of my life. Again, have fun making an ass of yourself.
|
|
sixclaws13 Male, 18-29, Midwest US
   2308 Posts
|
Monday, February 02, 2009 8:39:13 AM Someone pissed in Altarus Cheerios this morning, apparently. Have fun being an angsty 16 year old, when you're ready to join the real world let someone know. |
|
SilverThread Male, 30-39, Western US
   1353 Posts
|
Sunday, February 01, 2009 10:02:40 PM "...instrumentalize the public fear of terror to justify..."Isn't this video attempting to accomplish the same thing it accuses the "Government" of? I am more fearful of Corporations eavesdropping on my privacy than I am of the Government. |
|
Altaru Male, 13-17, Eastern US
   699 Posts
|
Sunday, February 01, 2009 7:56:18 PM "If you think your fellow man is so evil that he can not be trusted, what makes you think the men in the government are so much better?"A) I never said that I had any more faith in the government. I said that the way people automatically assume that everyone in power is going to turn corrupt is just as stupid as believeing that most "normal" people are "good." B) Considering that I ceased the arguement by admitting that this had turned into a pissing contest, and that all this bullsh*t was pointless, and NOONE ELSE has argued here since, you are now officially a dumbass, for being late to the party. Have fun making as ass of yourself.
|
|
sixclaws13 Male, 18-29, Midwest US
   2308 Posts
|
Sunday, February 01, 2009 6:37:34 PM ""Faith in your fellow man" is what's gotten the world into one hell of a lot of messes.Including this one, and the economic crisis we're in right now. ... I learned a LONG time ago not to have faith in my fellow man," because they're not worth it." A. Faith in the government has gotten us into this economic crisis, not faith in the common man. B. If you think your fellow man is so evil that he can not be trusted, what makes you think the men in the government are so much better? To quote Frederic Bastiat: "If the natural tendencies of mankind are so bad that it is not safe to permit people to be free, how is it that the tendencies of these organizers are always good? Do not the legislators and their appointed agents also belong to the human race? Or do they believe that they themselves are made of a finer clay than the rest of mankind?" |
|
Altaru Male, 13-17, Eastern US
   699 Posts
|
Sunday, February 01, 2009 4:21:26 PM This is pointless. It's turned into a pissing contest.It's a case of "I think you're a moron, and you know I'm an idiot." I'm right, your wrong, you're thinking the same thing, let's just end this stupid f*cking charade and go on with our lives. |
|
Mjustin Male, 18-29, Western US
   322 Posts
|
Sunday, February 01, 2009 4:17:07 PM "Show me an example of where these rights have been taken away."Ever heard of a Free Speech Zone? "It WON'T TAKE AWAY EVERYTHING." History shows that a government will take away your most basic rights if you let it. "If you're smart enough, you can get around it all anyway." Irrelevant. That's not what this is about and you know it. "The only people that will actually suffer from much of this are the people that either A) Do something illegal, or B)aren't smart enough to figure out a way around the system" The thing is, when governments get like this they start to make things like dissent illegal. They start to make it illegal to belong to a particular religion or to hold particular opinions. That's what happens, and that's what needs to be prevented. |
|
Mjustin Male, 18-29, Western US
   322 Posts
|
Sunday, February 01, 2009 4:11:19 PM "A) I never SAID the government should have full control over us."I didn't say full control. "B) I called you all a bunch of hypocrites because you seem to think that people AREN'T evil, but power automatically MAKES them evil." Great, now you're attacking straw men. "C) Maybe you should present me a valid example of where giving someone power automatically makes them corrupt. I asked that first, and you seem to have doged the issue. Just like anyone of your type will. If you don't like the question, you never heard it." Yet another straw man, and a generalization. Are you even trying to make a valid point? |
|
Altaru Male, 13-17, Eastern US
   699 Posts
|
Sunday, February 01, 2009 3:58:46 PM "You seem to have this idea that the constitution and human rights in general aren't important, as has been heavily implied by your posts, and by your complacency in allowing your rights and the rights of those around you to be stripped away."Show me an example of where these rights have been taken away. I can still say whatever I want on here, can I not? I'm still allowed to tell stories about getting a BJ from my GF over the phone, am I not? I haven't gotten any blackmail letters from the government, even when I said the same things I normally do while on the watchlist. It WON'T TAKE AWAY EVERYTHING. If you're smart enough, you can get around it all anyway. If you're not, well, learn to live with the system because the idiots have always been slaves anyway, whether they knew it or not. The only people that will actually suffer from much of this are the people that either A) Do something illegal, or B)aren't smart enough to figure out a way around the system |
|
Altaru Male, 13-17, Eastern US
   699 Posts
|
Sunday, February 01, 2009 3:53:38 PM "Can you give a valid reason as to why the government should be allowed to own all of us and have such control over us"A) I never SAID the government should have full control over us. B) I called you all a bunch of hypocrites because you seem to think that people AREN'T evil, but power automatically MAKES them evil. But people have a conscience, according to you a least. C) Maybe you should present me a valid example of where giving someone power automatically makes them corrupt. I asked that first, and you seem to have doged the issue. Just like anyone of your type will. If you don't like the question, you never heard it. |
|
nicalobe Male, 18-29, Midwest US
   108 Posts
|
Sunday, February 01, 2009 3:52:03 PM All I got from this vid is the Big Brother system will stop crime.Sounds good to me, where do I sign up? |
|
amaqdrinker Male, 18-29, Eastern US
   2231 Posts
|
Sunday, February 01, 2009 3:17:07 PM "Obviously you've never suffered at the hands of someone you thought you could trust. I'm speaking to a deaf man."i'm really not trying to be an assh*le right now, but you should just talk to someone about this. don't vent online, find a friend or a teacher or someone to talk about this with. please take my word that i am being sincere right now. |
|
capt_weasle Male, 13-17, Western US
 26 Posts
|
Sunday, February 01, 2009 3:00:49 PM You mean the government will know the color of my eyes? Oh god, not that! |
|
Mjustin Male, 18-29, Western US
   322 Posts
|
Sunday, February 01, 2009 2:57:00 PM Altaru, you seem to be confused on the meaning of the word "hypocrite." You so far have only demonstrated that you don't know what the term means, instead using it as an instant argument winner in lieu of an actual argument.You seem to have this idea that the constitution and human rights in general aren't important, as has been heavily implied by your posts, and by your complacency in allowing your rights and the rights of those around you to be stripped away. Can you give a valid reason as to why the government should be allowed to own all of us and have such control over us, or are you going to keep whining about how evil everyone is and calling people hypocrites when they clearly aren't? Don't punish the world for your own misanthropy. |
|
Animecha Male, 18-29, Western US
   78 Posts
|
Sunday, February 01, 2009 2:53:27 PM I think this video is hypocritical in that it uses fear the same way it claims that the government does in order to convince you of their side. Not to mention its logically fallacious since it describes the loss of zones of privacy and then immediately equates privacy to freedom without any direct correlation. The fear it employs isn't even really that evident either, it argues the "Who watches the watchers" idea in that anyone with the power to observe will abuse that information but its simply an assumption that they will.I personally think that this is an inevitable outcome of the onset of advanced technology. More people are now capable of more advanced crimes and the materials involved are becoming easier to acquire. It maybe that this surveillance will be the only prevention down the line when we enter an age where people will be able to build nukes and create viruses in their basements. |
|
Altaru Male, 13-17, Eastern US
   699 Posts
|
Sunday, February 01, 2009 2:49:27 PM Oh? Off-base you say?How many people in history have had power and stayed decent people? How many could have led an army and destroyed entire nations, slaughtered hundreds of thousands of people, could have ordered an uprising... But didn't? The quote, is bullsh*t, plain and simple, because there are hundreds of examples that can dis-prove it as easily as it can be proven. Put a gun in a mans hands. That's giving him power, power to kill you and a number of people around him. According to you and Mjustin, you would trust him NOT to pull the trigger. Because, as you said, you have "faith in your fellow man," and as Mjustin said, "most people aren't like that. The vast majority of people aren't being held back from killing others by a law; they're held back by their own conscience." I MYSELF didn't call bullsh*t on the quote. This so called "conscience" called bullsh*t. You're a bunch of hypocrites. |
|
amaqdrinker Male, 18-29, Eastern US
   2231 Posts
|
Sunday, February 01, 2009 2:46:24 PM do you even realize how our government works? our government is based around the knowledge that power corrupts. the system of checks and balances makes sure that the power is divided among the different branches. wise men wrote our constitution and it has kept the power of the government under control. as we become more of a capitalist democracy, however, this power is being shifted to the wealthy who are gaining increasingly more control over the government. |
|
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 Next >
|
|