Taylor Swift Releases A Remake Of Earth, Wind, and Fire's "September" -- How Bad Is It?

Submitted by: daegog 5 months ago in Entertainment


The video on top is Swift's version. The clip below if the original. Has there ever been a worse cover version of any song?

There are 30 comments:
Male 493
She shouldn't have done this.........and a banjo....really. Who does she think she is Justin Timberlake?
1
Reply
Male 2,591
I kind of like it. Gives it a completely different feel. Did feel like they could have used something besides the banjo though. 
0
Reply
Male 651
Needs a ball-gag and lube.
2
Reply
Male 1,782
Is it still fashionable to hate her? Oooh ooh let me do one. 

What a dumb bitch hehehehehe
0
Reply
Male 6,695
marsii Its not hating her, its that horrible song.

Maurice White is rolling in his grave at this abomination.
1
Reply
Male 31
daegog just the song is a abomination ... gosh i hate that song sing by monkey 
0
Reply
Male 174
daegog who is Earth, Wind, and Fire? and why should they be relevant in the year 2018? 
-2
Reply
Male 6,695
dieseljuice1891 Couldn't you ask that same question about every single artist from every genre before 1980?

Is Queen relevant?  The Beatles?  Hendrix?  Chopin or Wagner?
1
Reply
Male 12,222
I really liked the video effect in the 70's one
-1
Reply
Male 503
I always preferred this cover...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FuOuUixdSvY
0
Reply
Male 3,971
In answer to your query, pretty fucking bad.
1
Reply
Male 44,361
I couldn't relax and listen. Every time I hear a banjo my ass puckers up. Distracting.

3
Reply
Male 2,120
Gerry1of1 mood music?:)
1
Reply
Male 4,316
Gerry1of1 Another disser of the banjo! *Shake banjo harder*

2
Reply
Male 5,109
DuckBoy87 yep, guess they never heard of Bela Fleck.
-1
Reply
Male 1,546
trimble Bela Fleck did master the banjo but you can't change their minds if they don't like the instrument....kind of like if you listened to the all time greatest bagpiper
0
Reply
Male 266
Auto-tune+banjo+stepping on the classics= bad time for everyone.
2
Reply
1,050
I like TayTay but she's deffinitly better of writing her own music. 
0
Reply
Male 697
Bad. And not in a good way.
1
Reply
Male 4,316
I could watch her sing badly all day! <3
(I haven't actually watched the video yet, and won't be able to for a while)

I actually just saw Earth Wind and Fire live last month; 30 years old, and that was my first ever live concert (excluding the symphony, and any performance I've been in [read amateur hour])
0
Reply
Male 8,563
Banjo?!
0
Reply
Male 4,316
squrlz4ever Are you dissing banjos? *Pulls out my banjo ready to smack a squirrel* Well, I'm not dedicated learning this thing, might as well put it to good use!
0
Reply
Male 8,563
DuckBoy87 *poinga* *plinka* *poinga* ... Music needs banjos like squirrels need submarines.

"WHOOOOAAAA! Emergency Dive!"

0
Reply
Male 6,695
squrlz4ever pretty sure you need thumbs to operate submarines, just saying.
1
Reply
Male 8,563
daegog *fume*
0
Reply
Male 17,620
She's fuckable, so I think it's swell. I wouldn't want to listen to it again with mute off, but it's fine.
0
Reply
Male 8,563
Draculya She's fuckable, provided you think 30 minutes of lust is worth putting up with 10 years of listening to her sing about how you done her wronnn-ooooonnnnnng! And didn't respond to her teeeeeeeeee-xt messsageeeees! And forgot her birrrrrrrrrrtthdaaaaaaaay. You get the idea.
0
Reply
Male 2,120
squrlz4ever did Taylor hurt you?  Be honest.
0
Reply
Male 8,563
woodyville06 Yush. *sniffle*
0
Reply
Male 6,695
Draculya She is?  Well she is a breathing female without visible disfigurement so i guess she has that box checked.  That's probably the ONLY box she has checked.
0
Reply