Is Your Halloween Costume Racist? [Pic/Infographic

Submitted by: fancylad 3 years ago Funny

When you think about it, pretty much everything"s racist nowadays.
There are 67 comments:
Male 36,558
@HarryDresden:



I KNOW! He SMOKES!! That`s going to offend lots of people!!! ;-)

@LuckyDave: Yes, people MIGHT BE offended, it`s a risk, that is true! But to say a symbol must be banned because it "might offend"? That`s just not OK!

By the way? I`m offended by the Letter "M". It violates my religious beliefs. I hereby demand it be removed from use... see?
0
Reply
Male 99
hmm good thing i didn`t make a red skull costume this year then
0
Reply
Male 14,775
I`d like to point out the cross was also a Nazi symbol. Why ban a eastern religious symbol and not the cross?
0
Reply
Male 675
@5cats
I never meant to imply that it is inherently evil, only that it is entirely understandable why someone would find it unsettling.

@ghoulie11
Said to the man who suggested you dress in as many racist costumes as you can.
0
Reply
Male 36,558
@LuckyDave: It does "need context" that much is true! I agree! it is indeed associated with a VERY BAD thing.

But... that means that it IS INDEED `ok` in some other situations, yes?

So... it`s NOT `inherently evil`... correct?
0
Reply
Male 359
@LuckyDave

That doesn`t mean that a person doesn`t have the right to wear whatever they want. In context or not, it`s not against the law to offend somebody else`s sensibilities.
0
Reply
Female 7,838
I like living over here- I get to wear my nice black velvet evening gown, a drop of talc for powder mauve eyeshadow and that is me sorted.
0
Reply
Male 675
By the way, if we really want to confuse people, go as a blackface gay Jewish SS officer for Halloween.
0
Reply
Male 14,330
[quote]CONTEXT MAN![/quote]

The context of what we were talking about shows it`s a blatant double standard.
0
Reply
Male 675
Here`s the problem with the swastika(*), it -needs- context. If you place it in a Hindu or Buddhist context it is understood and fine, but without context it is often seen as a sign of white supremacy. Now the Confederate flag on the other hand, since we want to get down to the roots of each symbol, is a symbol of rebellion, separation from the Union, and everything the Confederacy stood for. Like it or not one of those beliefs was slavery, so you cannot fault someone for seeing it as a symbol of such. We can get into a philosophical conversation about symbols and signs but my point is that symbols get lost in their own context, regardless of what anyone elses context is someone will likely be offended no matter your intent. You may disagree with the person but they still have a point, however small.
0
Reply
Male 7,123
OK. I`m reclame.
0
Reply
Male 2,357
@LordJim

[quote]Reclame? Is that some sort of knitting pattern?[/quote]
Reclame is public acknowledgement/attention. You could have found that definition without my help.
0
Reply
Male 7,123
Reclame? Is that some sort of knitting pattern? I have no idea what you are talking about.
0
Reply
Male 2,357
@LordJim

[quote]Kudos? Are we still saying kudos? Wht was your point?[/quote]
I suppose we are since I`ve said it once, and you twice now. My point was to provide you with the reclame you apparently desire so.
0
Reply
Male 7,123
HumanAction

Kudos? Are we still saying kudos? Wht was your point?
0
Reply
Male 7,123
CONTEXT MAN!

Yes, what is acceptable at a white supremacist social gathering might draw criticism anywhere else. Context.
0
Reply
Male 7,123
McGovern1981

My beloved prince? I`m a republican.
0
Reply
Male 36,558
[quote]Sexy-scary would be a bonus.[/quote]
@LordJim: Quite correct!! Also good are:
Funny-Scary
Thoughtful-Scary
Ironic-Scary (very rare)

Apparently in that movie? A white guy gets the role of a black man despite many blacks trying out for it. So he wears "blackface" to be "blacker than the blacks are". I haven`t seen it either.

[quote]a tourist with a swastika pendant try to argue that point in a bus in Israel.[/quote]

CONTEXT MAN!
If a woman visits MANY (not every) African nations? She WILL NOT wear pants - or else! It is TABOO!
Walk around the streets of Mecca with a "Picture of Mohammed" t-shirt? Yeah, good luck!



No! Not THAT Muhammad! lolz! Although it would also be illegal in Mecca...

IRONY ALERT: A -white Muhammad Ali- t-shirt... :-)
0
Reply
Male 2,357
@LordJim

[quote]Women who refuse to be subordinated have ... `grown a pair.` What?[/quote]
I see that you`ve added `sense of humor` to the list of attributes you do not possess. Kudos.
0
Reply
Male 7,123
I`ve heard of two of those people.
0
Reply
Male 14,330
[quote]b) A bigot who thinks they can get a pass once a year.

Actually, it just b). [/quote]

Unless your black following your logic.


Seem your beloved prince is a bigot BTW...
0
Reply
Male 7,123
HumanAction

Women who refuse to be subordinated have ... `grown a pair.` What?
0
Reply
Male 14,330
[quote]
Somebody I`ve never heard of whited-up in a movie I never saw so black-face is now fine and not racist? [/quote]

SO cause you`ve never seen it or heard of them it can`t be racist making white face not and black face racist.... OK, logic indeed!


Never heard of Eddy Murphy, Dave Chapple, Keenen Ivory Wayans or Shawn Wayans amongst many others who`ve done it WOW!
0
Reply
Male 36,558
@LuckyDave: The swastika is a "basic geometric design" that has been around since writing was invented.
When used IN CONTEXT with Nazism? Then it`s "bad".
There`s countless 100+ year old items and pictures with the swastika in it`s various forms on them. They PRE-DATE Nazism! HOW could they be considered "Nazi symbols"?



"Old Navajo Blanket"



The "Windsor Swastikas" Hockey team: 1910.

-My- God is a mysterious creature... ;-)
0
Reply
Male 7,123
HumanActionThe swastika is still widely used in a variety of religions (Hinduism, Buddhism, could be more). The context of its usage decides the intent of the symbol..`

I once saw a tourist with a swastika pendant try to argue that point in a bus in Israel. It did not go well for him.

If your costume pisses off a significant number of people then you are either;

a) a hip, witty, transgressive and ironic intellectual who is heroically defending freedom of expression by refusing to bend to political correctness and double standards.

or

b) A bigot who thinks they can get a pass once a year.

Actually, it just b).

`
0
Reply
Male 14,330
@LordJim

Well lets see one is making light of a genocide. Which would actually be a pretty good costume if you were like a zombie too! The other is a people crying racist over something they do the exact same thing with but claim it`s not racist somehow because it`s white. Either stop doing both or shut the f uck up and don`t be a perpetually offended pussy.
0
Reply
Male 7,123
McGovern1981

Not getting the cultural references. I guess I didn`t see the movie.

Somebody I`ve never heard of whited-up in a movie I never saw so black-face is now fine and not racist?

OK. Logic.
0
Reply
Male 7,123
I thought the point of halloween costumes was to come to the event as something scary. Sexy-scary would be a bonus.

A lot of the comments here seem to be saying `How far can I go in stereotyping/mocking another race/culture and still indignantly claim not to be racist.?`

Just like a lot of comments about rape seem to be asking `How far can I go and still get away with saying it wasn`t rape?`

I`m basically Scots and if someone decides to wear a kilt, sporran and ginger wig I`m not offended. So If I decide to stick a yellow star onto a pair of striped pyjamas, stencil a number onto my arm. apply a little gaunt make-up and show up as a concentration camp inmate that should be OK and beyond criticism because I`m OK with non-scots wearing humorous kilts? We wouldn`t want any double standards, would we?

0
Reply
Male 2,357
@LuckyDave

The swastika is still widely used in a variety of religions (Hinduism, Buddhism, could be more). The context of its usage decides the intent of the symbol; this was my point to SmagBoy.

You should not dismiss the swastika as wholly anti-Semitic nor should you dismiss the Confederate flag as wholly racist. While it`s possible they can be used in such a context, the symbols alone are not malicious.

For example, few of us would consider a thumbs up to be offensive. Yet, in the Middle East, it is so (or so I`m told). Therefore, the symbol itself cannot be offensive; rather, the context in which it is used can be.
0
Reply
Male 675
Yes Fred, another symbol that has lost most of its meaning because of actions taken by someone else.

Still looking for your God.
0
Reply
Male 14,330
0
Reply
Male 14,330
@FredSpudman

Halloween LOL some make a career out of it! VV


Culture of double standards.
0
Reply
Male 653
@Wonderwmn Who are "they"? And do blacks often "white up" for Halloween and such? Are you seriously suggesting Halloween was only fun when you could black up?
0
Reply
Female 164
They took all the fun out of Halloween :( It`s ok for blacks to dress up as whites, but if whites dress up as blacks... SHAME ON YOU!!
0
Reply
Male 27

0
Reply
Male 500
som-tam

I`d like to start clapping really slowly right now. Well said, very well said.
0
Reply
Male 714
so... if you are this colour you can do something but if you are that colour you can`t do that same thing because some people that were the same colour as you did a mean thing to the people of the colour that can do the thing.

We should harking back to the past to justify double standards, and to shame people into feeling guilty for something they didn`t do, most likely are not descended from the people who did it and can objectively be described as not hating or discriminating against people of different races.

We might start to see more harmony if resentment and hatred were not continuously stirred up by the people who claim to be against such things.
0
Reply
Male 714
@jtrebowski: That... that never happened, did it.
0
Reply
Male 653
@LuckyDave The swastika is an ancient Indian symbol espoused by the Nazis for their own cynical ends. It`s identical to the Stars and Bars in that respect. You were saying something about a god?
0
Reply
Male 7,364
SmagBoy1-"The black face is racist, the white face is not."

And that is why there will always be a schism.

Either both are, or both are not.

The double-standard goes back to the `We want to be equal, except for privilages.`
0
Reply
Male 675
If you go in blackface as a specific person, say Lil` Wayne, then black people aren`t the costume, Lil` Wayne is. Besides, no one should care if the costume is racist, are you? No? Then enjoy the one night of the year where it is acceptable for women to go out in public dressed as sluts, and no one cares. If they can do that, dress however the hell you want.

PS @HumanAction

The Swastica.

Where is your God now?
0
Reply
Male 3,364
A few years ago, I attached some tea bags to a cap with the confederate flag on it, and carried a nerf gun, and a sign that said "Obama is an Kenyan mooslimb soshulist". It tool a full hour until they realized I was making fun of them, and that, folks, is how to find out how easily offended conservatives are too.
0
Reply
Male 3,060
Well... I guess I just made a comment to explain that... You know what I mean though.
0
Reply
Male 3,060
I`d comment, but I`ve already said everything I needed to in the last race/costume related post.
0
Reply
Male 3,909
@SmagBoy1 - It`s whiny little apologists like you who keep this problem front and center. As long as that double standard exists no one will ever truly be equal.
0
Reply
Male 2,357
@SmagBoy

Since you`ve apparently forgotten what you wrote earlier, allow me to repost it:

[quote]anyone who doesn`t get that probably says the Confederate flag isn`t a racist symbol[/quote]
Ah, so you`re essentially suggesting that the Confederate flag is absolutely a racist symbol. Yet, how can this be? The flag was made by people who started a war that had nothing to do with race or slavery.

Ah, but you say it`s been repurposed via the KKK and that it`s completely lost its meaning. Well *of course* it has. Despite having nothing to do with racism or slavery at the time of its conception, *of course* the flag can only mean one thing - that black people suck.

I`m not entirely sure you`ll have picked up on the sarcasm, so, that last paragraph was written sarcastically. Don`t say I never did anything for you.
0
Reply
Male 4,431
That`s exactly right, whodat6484. The black face is racist, the white face is not. That you don`t understand that is not only sad, it`s entirely predictable.
0
Reply
Male 4,431
HumanAction, do you understand that what the Civil War was about and the reemergence of the Confederate flag as a symbol of the KKK are two separate issues separated by several decades? Do you understand that the Confederate flag had all but died out and was no longer seen until the KKK repurposed it? Please read up on racist history in our country before you presume to lecture me on the secession.
0
Reply
Male 2,357
@DrProfessor

[quote]It *would* be if white people and black people had always been on completely equal terms.[/quote]
This a ridiculous and completely unattainable standard. Never in history have any two groups met this criteria.

Is it offensive to dress as a woman? They`ve certainly had a rough hundred or so thousand of years.
Is it offensive to dress as an Irishman? They were discriminated against in the US.
Is it offensive to dress as a lumberjack? In doing so, you`d almost certainly be perpetuating an unfair stereotype in some manner.

Let`s face it, in all of history, women have had a much worse time than black people. In many parts of the world, they`re still essentially slaves. Somehow, though, they`ve managed to grow a pair big enough to allow them to handle a few guys dressings up for one night a year.
0
Reply
Male 2,357
It`s not often I agree with @whodat, but when I do, I prefer it to be about racism (or lack thereof).

@Smagboy

[quote] Not understanding history is not an excuse.[/quote]
I`m not entirely convinced that you understood the primary reasons the South attempted to secede from the Union. For example, are you aware that the Civil War began (and the Confederate Flag existed) well before the Emancipation Proclamation was even dreamt up?

I think that means that the flag isn`t racist and that the Civil War wasn`t about the racist South.
0
Reply
Male 3,894
@whodat6484--It *would* be if white people and black people had always been on completely equal terms. While the process of imitating a race (even white) is in and of itself somewhat offensive, and generally tasteless, the point here is that blackface is offensive to a much larger degree.

Why? Because it was used to degrade and dehumanize people entirely on account of their skin color. It was used to create stereotypes that perpetuate even into the present day, albeit in different, less obvious forms. It reminds those people of the disparity in power that existed, and the horrors their people endured in this country.

That`s what makes it more of a sore point than someone in whiteface. Nobody ever used whiteface that way. If there was a country in which things were reversed, it would be just as inappropriate.

That`s what people, especially on this website, never seem to understand. They try to look at things in a vacuum, and you can`t do that.
0
Reply
Male 3,909
@SmagBoy1 - No, the logic is weak with you. You`re saying that...

This = Racist




...and...


This = NOT Racist


0
Reply
Male 1,931
Women dig Quailman, though.

0
Reply
Male 1,237
@whodat I can only imagine the uproar surrounding "Black Chicks"
0
Reply
Male 1,237
Ha, sexy that race
0
Reply
Male 4,431
@whodat6484: "If it`s considered racist for group A to imitate group B, then the same must be true if the roles are reversed."

The logic is weak with you, isn`t it?
0
Reply
Male 4,431
Hey, ElMustache, I`m a white dude, and I totally get it. So let`s generalize, mmmm-kay? Thing is, when something has been used to demean (specifically, blackface), and for decades in popular white entertainment, then, yeah, it`s effing racist. And anyone who doesn`t get that probably says the Confederate flag isn`t a racist symbol, either ("What, it`s part of my heritage!"). Not understanding history is not an excuse.

Point is, please don`t generalize. It`s not as bad as a white person doing black face, but dang.
0
Reply
Female 3,696
There is no difference between painting yourself dark brown to cosplay as a real or fictional character or painting yourself blue to be an x-men, it`s not generalizing a race, it`s a fact about a single person and I hate that people get in poop for this.
0
Reply
Male 37,914
0
Reply
Male 3,909
@DrProfessor - I`m well aware of races being caricatured throughout history. If it`s considered racist for group A to imitate group B, then the same must be true if the roles are reversed. Otherwise you have what is called a double standard. It`s not that hard to figure out.
0
Reply
Male 1,625
No, Jake. It`s not even remotely the same. I don`t expect you to understand.

An over whelming majority of IABers are white dudes, and you guys have no perspective of what it might be like for another race or gender. You don`t see Latinos, Asians, or African Americans dressing in Whiteface as William Wallace, or going as a Leprechaun, or with Leiderhose and a bobsled, etc. But yet, whenever someone says "hey man, brown/black/yellow face might be insensitive" what do all of you say?

F*ck you, it`s just a joke. It`s just a costume.

I`m not saying you can`t dress up as ethnic characters, a good costume is a good costume. I would love to see more tastefully done ethnic costumes. At least have the sensitivity and awareness to know that you are donning something that is not your own, and you should do it respectfully.

Agree with ajd.
0
Reply
Male 3,894
Male 7,031

If you can have this guy on millions of pizza boxes, you can wear a sombrero at Halloween ...

0
Reply
Male 634
Dressing up as a specific person should be OK, dressing up as a generic caricature of a race or ethnic group should not be OK.
0
Reply
Male 3,909
"Does it involve the use of blackface?"

If blackface is racist then so is whiteface.


0
Reply
Male 1,109
Yeah, drat them if they can`t take a joke
0
Reply
Male 19,888
Link: Is Your Halloween Costume Racist? [Pic/Infographic [Rate Link] - When you think about it, pretty much everything`s racist nowadays.
0
Reply