The Last Letter: A Message To GWB & Cheney [Pic+]

Submitted by: chalket 4 years ago in

Tomas Young"s last letter, written in hospice, "thanking" them for their contributions to democracy.
There are 39 comments:
Male 8,132
CrakrJak

"if he had been sent to Afghanistan"

Yes. The war that was in response to the attack on our country by a group of people in Afghanistan. DEFENSE.
0
Reply
Male 10,855
Bud I sympathize, Iraq war was a BAD idea destined for failure. Nonetheless, learn to read beyond the spin and euphemisms ESPECIALLY when you`re signing a contract with Uncle Sam. In this case you signed up to fight anyone congress (or the President) deems an "enemy".
0
Reply
Male 17,512
HG: "He...signed up to DEFEND his country."

You obviously didn`t read the whole letter, he says that he wouldn`t be whining (total bullsh|t) if he had been sent to Afghanistan.

Besides that the oath of enlistment he took says, "I, (NAME), do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; and that I will obey the orders of the President of the United States and the orders of the officers appointed over me, according to regulations and the Uniform Code of Military Justice. So help me God."

Please take particular note of that "..all enemies, foreign and domestic.." part. It doesn`t say "some enemies" or "only the enemies I want to fight against".

So once again, Yes, he did indeed sign up for that.
0
Reply
Male 1,268
The moment the planes hit the twin towers I KNEW we were going to war with Iraq. Absolutely knew it. I finally made it to boot camp by November.
0
Reply
Male 4,395
"Because he didn`t order the death of an American citizen without his right to due process?"

You mean Anwar al-Aulaqi the American traitor who was living in Yemini and recruiting for al-Qaeda? The guy the Saudi news station Al Arabiya described as the "bin Laden of the Internet? Yes, it was unprecedented for President Obama to put him on the CIA terrorist kill list but seeing who he actually was and what he was doing I don`t blame him one bit. Who knows how many lives Obama saved by ordering the killing of this al-Qaeda recruiter. Conservatives would have been fine if Bush had ordered the strike but since it was Obama they have turned into pussy liberals with this issue. Ha ha.
0
Reply
Male 3,445
"Nope, they had people there, they had people all over the Middle East, Europe, the Mediterranean just biding their time. We went to Afghanistan first and got rid of training camps, then when the decision was made to go to Iraq the action there slowed down they waited to hear from their guys who were already in country as to whether or not coalition forces were going there."

When I say presence, I mean an actual fighting presence. They may have had a few agents, but Saddam was no friend of Al Qaeda.

"When they got good enough info they literally just followed us over there."

Again, that just underscores my point. The only reason there was a foreign insurgency in Iraq was because we were there.
0
Reply
Male 210
Dick Cheney`s company, KBR, got a military contract to coat pipes with a powerfully carcinogenic substance to protect them. Their negligence fatally poisoned U.S. soldiers in the process. Guess who is expected to foot the bill?

Cheney`s a POS
0
Reply
Male 3,909
@paperduck - There`s a big difference between being "not fond of" someone and being scared to death or someone to the point where you do whatever they say because you fear for your life as well as the lives of your family. That`s how the Iraqis lived while Saddam was in power. Those were the people who were coming out and saying thank you, not shooting at us.

"Al Qaeda didn`t have a presence in Iraq until after Saddam was toppled."

Nope, they had people there, they had people all over the Middle East, Europe, the Mediterranean just biding their time. We went to Afghanistan first and got rid of training camps, then when the decision was made to go to Iraq the action there slowed down they waited to hear from their guys who were already in country as to whether or not coalition forces were going there. When they got good enough info they literally just followed us over there.
0
Reply
Male 8,132
MelCervini

"death of an American citizen"

1. Please explain to me how an American life is so much more valuable than any other life.

2. Well Bush ordered the Iraq invasion which caused thousands of American deaths. Is that OK?
0
Reply
Female 3,392
"First the drone program was started under President Bush and there was zero problem with it from the Republicans - zero. If the program was worthy of war crimes why did the Republicans not put an immediate end to it when it was initiated under Bush?"

Because he didn`t order the death of an American citizen without his right to due process?
0
Reply
Male 3,445
`The majority of the "insurgents" we came across weren`t even Iraqi, the actual Iraqis basically said, "What? Saddam`s gone? F*ck yeah, it`s party time!"`

Doesn`t this just highlight the other major folly of the Iraq war, that it opened the door for a foreign insurgency? Al Qaeda didn`t have a presence in Iraq until after Saddam was toppled.
0
Reply
Male 4,431
Afghanistan made sense to me. Well, for the few days we thought OBL was there. Then, we should have left there and gone to Pakistan. Why we *ever* went to Iraq, I have no clue. And here`s something: even if they *did* have WMDs, why would that have mattered? Were they going to float them over to us rafts? Tie them to birds and fly them over? We went to Iraq for exactly the reasons this letter says, and nothing else. And it`s a crying damned shame. Oh well.
0
Reply
Male 1,745
Whodat I`m not too fond of Obama, but if a foreign country invades to remove him I`m shooting at them. You can sugar coat the Iraq invasion all you want (saying they weren`t even Iraqi) but as much as I didn`t want a single military person to be killed or injured, I can understand them taking up arms. I would do the same thing here if anyone invaded. That is actual defending of my family and community, it becomes personal.
0
Reply
Male 4,395
Fifteen of the nineteen 9/11 hijackers were from Saudi Arabia. Why was Saudi Arabia not held accountable? Why did Bush give them a pass?
0
Reply
Male 4,395
"What Obama has done with his drone program is far more illegal than any wars under Bush, wars that Hillary, Biden, Reid, Feinstein, Dodd, and more authorized. And as I listed before, if you apply the same standard to all the presidents, they should all be tried. It`s flawed thinking."

First the drone program was started under President Bush and there was zero problem with it from the Republicans - zero. If the program was worthy of war crimes why did the Republicans not put an immediate end to it when it was initiated under Bush?

Iraq was a preemptive war against a country that was not an immediate threat to the US (Iran and North Korea were real threats). The Bush administration and the Republicans talked the country into the preemptive strike using lies and scare tactics. Someone should be held accountable.
0
Reply
Male 3,909
"We invade a country leading to tens of thousands of innocent deaths and anyone who fights back is labeled "an insurgent".

I guarantee no one will ever know the real reason we went into Iraq but regardless of that, Saddam needed to go. They wanted him gone because, as one Iraqi terp told me, "We`re tired of his sh*t and living in fear of speaking or even thinking anything that could be considered anti-Saddam." The majority of the Saddam controlled Iraqi soldiers literally stripped off their uniforms and left them along with their equipment in the positions they were dug into when they knew we were coming and when they heard he was gone. They only wore the uniform and did what he said out of fear that they & their families would "disappear" if they didn`t. The majority of the "insurgents" we came across weren`t even Iraqi, the actual Iraqis basically said, "What? Saddam`s gone? F*ck yeah, it`s party time!"
0
Reply
Male 1,243
Yet another reason why people around the world are chanting "DEATH TO THE PRESIDENCY!!!!!!!!!! DEATH TO THE PRESIDENCY!!!!!!!!!! DEATH TO THE PRESIDENCY!!!!!!!!!! DEATH TO THE PRESIDENCY!!!!!!!!!! DEATH TO THE PRESIDENCY!!!!!!!!!! DEATH TO THE PRESIDENCY!!!!!!!!!! DEATH TO THE PRESIDENCY!!!!!!!!!! DEATH TO THE PRESIDENCY!!!!!!!!!! DEATH TO THE PRESIDENCY!!!!!!!!!! DEATH TO THE PRESIDENCY!!!!!!!!!! DEATH TO THE PRESIDENCY!!!!!!!!!! DEATH TO THE PRESIDENCY!!!!!!!!!! DEATH TO THE PRESIDENCY!!!!!!!!!! DEATH TO THE PRESIDENCY!!!!!!!!!! DEATH TO THE PRESIDENCY!!!!!!!!!!..."

Join in the chant! Take it to the little white house on the hill. Stay. Chant. Grow in numbers. Chant. It`s your right. It`s your duty.
0
Reply
Male 8,132
paperduck

"(kind of like "insurgents" in the countries we invaded)"

Hilarious right? We invade a country leading to tens of thousands of innocent deaths and anyone who fights back is labeled "an insurgent".
0
Reply
Male 8,132
whodat6484

"Absolutely, you can ask any Veteran and they`ll tell you the same thing."

Then wouldn`t you agree that whether or not the letter of the contract gives them carte blanche to use you as they see fit it violates the spirit of the agreement in which you agree to lay down your life in defense of this country?

In that regard can you not sympathize with him in his anger at giving his life for what he feels was a violation of that commitment?
0
Reply
Male 1,745
I`ll "serve" if there is an invasion. By serve, I mean grab my guns, go outside and shoot invaders (kind of like "insurgents" in the countries we invaded). I wouldn`t join the military to be sent off half way around the world, because then I`m doing the invading.
0
Reply
Male 3,909
"...didn`t you feel that the people that commanded you owed it to you to only risk your life on matters that were worth that sacrifice?"

Absolutely, you can ask any Veteran and they`ll tell you the same thing. I still remember the day we heard we`d be going to Iraq at our morning formation. Everyone from the newest boot right out of SOI to our CO were in agreement that going into Iraq was stupid. Our CO told us he knew it was bullsh*t just like the rest of us but we all signed on the dotted line so we`re going whether we like it or not. Then, in typical Marine Corps fashion he said, "We`re Marines, we`re here to do a job and we`re going to do it. I`ll level with you, it`s going to suck, I guarantee that, but we`re going either way. Besides that, I have nothing else better to do and I could use a vacation to get away from my wife for a few months."
0
Reply
Male 8,132
whodat6484

"If you`d like to know why the "I didn`t sign up for this sh*t" argument doesn`t work I have some reading material to share with you."

You served. I didn`t. So in that regard I defer to you completely.

However, when you signed the contract and agreed to put your life on the line didn`t you feel that the people that commanded you owed it to you to only risk your life on matters that were worth that sacrifice?
0
Reply
Male 761
For what it`s worth, that`s on him. He joined.

I never wanted to join any branch, not out of lack of patriotism, but out of the realization that the people who are making these conflicts happen never serve, their kids generally never serve and that gives them the egotistical ability of putting lives in risk for meaningless purposes.

Personally, if you join the military you join with the expectation that you will die. Questioning the validity of the conflict after the fact is an exercise in futility.
0
Reply
Male 3,909
If you`d like to know why the "I didn`t sign up for this sh*t" argument doesn`t work I have some reading material to share with you. This is the actual enlistment contract that is signed when you swear in.

Enlistment/Reenlistment Document
Armed Forces of the United States
DD FORM 4/3
0
Reply
Male 3,909
He lost me at "I did not join the Army to go to Iraq..."

Once those words are spoken/typed, you no longer have my attention. Last time I checked there never was a draft like Vietnam, all those who served did so voluntarily for whatever their reason may have been. You know damn well when signing that contract and taking the Oath of Enlistment that for the next 4 years (or however may years you enlist) you`ll go wherever they tell you to go, whenever they tell you to go.

As for substandard care at the VA, it`s no secret that`s a problem but it depends on where you live. I use the VA and have had nothing short of top notch care from the Bronx VA Hospital and the Montrose, NY VA Hospital which has the best PTSD/Mental Health programs in the country.

0
Reply
Male 8,132
Andrew155

"Holygod, with the exception of Japan`s attacks on US territories, we haven`t had to defend our country since the civil war, and before that 1812."

I would argue that Afghanistan was in defense of this country. The removal of the government that harbored the organization that attacked us was a defensive action.

It could also be argued that defense on behalf of our allies is also an appropriate use of our military. So that would include the first war in Iraq, Korea, and Vietnam.

Even the military build up during the Cold War was a matter of defense.

It is pretty f.ucking hard to imagine how this invasion of Iraq, at the cost of 10s of thousands of lives, could possibly be equated to a defensive action.
0
Reply
Male 14,334
In Syria some group not sure which yet has used nerve gas or something similar geee I wonder where that came from......
0
Reply
Male 2,578
Holygod, with the exception of Japan`s attacks on US territories, we haven`t had to defend our country since the civil war, and before that 1812. I`m not counting the Mexican war. Anyone who is political literate is aware of the US`s fascination with foreign adventurism and knows that`s what they`re doing.
0
Reply
Male 2,578
Ignorant is a strong word. What Obama has done with his drone program is far more illegal than any wars under Bush, wars that Hillary, Biden, Reid, Feinstein, Dodd, and more authorized. And as I listed before, if you apply the same standard to all the presidents, they should all be tried. It`s flawed thinking.
0
Reply
Male 8,132
CrakrJak

"He says that "He didn`t sign up for that...". Sorry, but yes, yes you did."

No. He, like most people in the military signed up to DEFEND his country. You know what the word defend means right? It is what our military is supposed to be for. Iraq had nothing to do with DEFENDING this country.
0
Reply
Female 1,894
you guys are all ignorant... the only message he is trying to send is that the war is corrupt and he and all the other soldiers are not treated like hero’s but pawns because they are not doing heroic work.
0
Reply
Male 330
What an arrogant douche. The first two paragraphs of "I`m writing this on behalf of _______" automatically killed any of what he had to say, right or wrong. He can`t, and doesn`t, speak for the rest of the veterans (who have much more decency than this fool) or any of the other people groups he delineates.
0
Reply
Male 2,578
If Bush should be put on trial, Obama should be as well. And so should Hollande. I would also include Clinton because of Yugoslav wars and his Iraq sanctions that killed 500,000 children according to the UN. Reagan as well. Nixon, LBJ, and Kennedy also. The first two for Vietnam, the last for the build up to Vietnam plus the "illegal" invasions of Cuba and I`m sure a bunch of other stuff. FDR should be tried too, due to his draconian indiscriminate bombing of French, Dutch, German, and Japanese civilians.


Let`s just give everyone a trial. This is the best way to make our world a brighter tomorrow.
0
Reply
Male 17,512
Long story made short, he volunteered all gung ho and sh|t, got wounded in Iraq and then became a whiny bitch. This `last letter` of his disrespects every veteran and veteran`s family in our armed services. He says that "He didn`t sign up for that...". Sorry, but yes, yes you did. There was nothing in his induction papers that stated that he`d only fight where he wanted to fight, He joined wanting glory and praise for himself, not to serve our country.

After that he got substandard VA care, that we should be sorry for. That is a tragedy, something we have since tried to remedy. But that`s still no excuse for badmouthing your country. Sure he`s in pain, perhaps lashing out at everyone helps soothe his crushed ego. He didn`t come home the `big war hero` he thought he`d be, well boohoo.

There were men of my Dad`s generation that didn`t have a choice, they were drafted. And a far far greater percentage of them never came home alive.
0
Reply
Male 1,625
That was chilling.
0
Reply
Male 2,711
@McG
You stupid and uncaring, bro?
0
Reply
Male 2,468
[quote]*yawn*[/quote]
0
Reply
Male 14,334

0
Reply
Male 2,711
Link: The Last Letter: A Message To GWB & Cheney [Pic+] [Rate Link] - Tomas Young`s last letter, written in hospice, `thanking` them for their contributions to democracy.
0
Reply