Changing Education Paradigms

Submitted by: DickenMcHunt 6 years ago in

A clever adaptation of a speech given by Sir Ken Robinson, world-renowned education and expert.
There are 57 comments:
Female 582
After going through 17 years of education, I can tell you that 1) ADHD exists but it is often misdiagnosed and 2) divergent thinkers have the hardest time in school -- both academically and socially.
0
Reply
Male 3,915
Inversegrav:

"This was the first analysis of current education I have seen that makes sence to me.
I want to see the whole speech. "

....that makes.....sence?

that doesn`t make sense...
0
Reply
Male 3,842
[quote]What`s your theory?[/quote]

You may not realize it, but this question is one of the greatest conversation starters with anyone you meet. Everyone has a theory and most people are very eager to tell others about it.
0
Reply
Male 89
I`m going to Phoenix University to get my masters in business administration. It`s amazing how much we learn and get done in a class of 12 versus a class of 120.
0
Reply
Male 770
This was the first analysis of current education I have seen that makes sence to me.
I want to see the whole speech.
0
Reply
Female 327
The thing about the paper clip was kind of dumb. If it were 200 feet tall and made out of foam rubber, then it wouldn`t be a paper clip. Other than that, the video was really cool.
0
Reply
Female 812
At 11:09 the sound just stops.... So what`s the conclusion?!
0
Reply
Male 2,294
"Now, the user posits that it is because of education. Well, my guess is that the trend would be the same even if you take uneducated children who have never gone to school."

So, you basically agreed with him. Brilliant.
0
Reply
Male 2,419
@coedog
stop limiting your design space (that was what? rule #1 in design?)
0
Reply
Male 3,631
Best line: "Alas my Senses, I knew them well!" Maybe this is why I`ve yet to get that College degree..
0
Reply
Male 256
As an engineer and future educator, I say bull hockey. Yes, creativity is important, but so is hard science and knowledge. How many uses for this paper clip does not translate into how many uses for this bolt that holds a certain panel on the Airbus you`re riding in to get from LaLa land to home. Would you put a paper clip on that panel?
0
Reply
Male 757
REVOLUTION! it will come within 10 years, and when all the old pricks in government are dead after it society will flourish. drat the current government.
0
Reply
Male 3,915
class of 3000 anyone?
0
Reply
Female 7,867
I suspect I agree, but finding a workable model would not be easy. Secondly, while I agree that some people are smart in other ways that do badly in a standard model, we need to remember that some people are brighter than others- educated or not. How do we ensure that the best and the brightest are given the chance to excel? I agree that they are often let down by the current system- but it may be hard to ensure that any other model does not do a worse job.
0
Reply
Male 3,619
wat
0
Reply
Male 295
The test for divergent thinking would score higher for kindergärtners as they do not know what is normally possible. As people grow older they get to know the possible and discard other theories. If they do not do that, the sheer volume of information is too much for the human brain.

Now, the user posits that it is because of education. Well, my guess is that the trend would be the same even if you take uneducated children who have never gone to school.
0
Reply
Male 5,617
Sorry for being so aggressive but, my own theory is not just about standardized, age sorted batch education.

I think that the world is largely populated by people that have "someone else`s job" having taken a position strictly for employment`s sake.

Cops that follow regulations like machines, making them much more suited to manufacturing and machine operators that can find things lost, making them better suited to investigation.

Maybe I have an extremist`s perspective but, similar to what you described, I knew EXACTLY what I wanted to be when I was 10, in fact, on my 10th birthday.
Formal education then seemed to do a lot to discourage my ever being anything even close.
The bulk of what I use professionally came from informal self-education.
0
Reply
Female 59
This was a TED talk. Well I -think- this was a TED talk. It`s from Sir Ken Robinson which I admire greatly. This talk started so many debates with my friends, teachers and co-workers. He is absolutely right, but I wouldn`t know how we could change the model establish. Let me hunt down more from him (btw, I also think he is hilarious). Here:

Complementary videos:

Schools kill creativity

Bring on the learning revolution!
0
Reply
Female 383
THANK YOU! As a high school student, I agree fully with this man. I mean, by the time we get out of school, nothing I learned will be pratcical! More people than ever are getting great jobs based on their artistic capabilities rather than on their ability to solve math problems or what the concentration of a liquid is. It`s freaking ridiculous.
This speech had put it all into perspective, and gives me a good fighting chance at shutting up adults who bitch about education.
0
Reply
Male 1,016
I agree 100% with this man.
We, as humans, have grown as communities have become larger and our collective brain power has grown. Now that we are connected globally through telecommunications watch how fast things will develop.
0
Reply
Male 970
im impressed how this speech kept me focused.
0
Reply
Male 411
Very interesting
0
Reply
Male 89
I`m going to Phoenix University to get my masters in business administration. It`s amazing how much we learn and get done in a class of 12 versus a class of 120.
0
Reply
Male 758
I agree with you entirely, davymid.
I`m going back to school for my HVAC degree...one of those jobs you`d think is menial and blue-collar...and to a degree, it is. But I also have my degree in Nuclear Engineering. It`s just that I find the puzzle involved in fixing a complicated machine like an HVAC system to be as stimulating as you find rocks (which I am interested in, too...I love driving through the mountains and inspecting the layers in the cuts through the mountain). Nuclear engineering is interesting, but not as practical or useful where I live.

Also, great video to watch after smoking a bowl.
(Totally blew my credibility there...lol).
0
Reply
Male 64
I like how Oregon, Idaho, and Washington are just one shapeless blob on the map. THANKS.
And we have plenty of ADHD here on the west coas-- WOAH A SQUIRREL!
0
Reply
Male 12,138
(sorry for double, ran out of characters)

The only point I was making is that people assume people with degrees coming out of their yin-yang (myself included) are not necessarily *more intelligent* than your plumber, or the guy who lays your floors. My brother for example is a greenkeeper on a golf course. Took a different path in life than I did (the academic path). He is EVERY BIT (if not moreso) as intelligent as me.

I like the way this clip challenges us to perceive the way we think about education. And this coming from a guy that very much benefitted from the kind of educational elitism which is pointed out in this clip as being a bit outdated.
0
Reply
Male 12,138
[quote]Not "technically." You ARE "Dr. Davymid." It`s a matter of your making people CALL YOU "Dr. Davymid" which will happen after you FEEL like a "Dr. Davymid"[/quote]
Sure, I feel like a Dr. Got my doctorate 8 years ago. But I never refer to myself, nor introduce myself, nor do I have on my business card "Dr.". My business card reads (real name withheld), Davymid, PhD.

[quote]Do you even like geology?[/quote]
Of course I do. As a kid, I was the one picking up rocks on the seashore to take home. An understanding of the natural world (which goes beyond geology, extends very much to zoology, biology, climatology, cosmology) is the very essence of who I am. I more than like geology, I love it with a deep burning passion that defines who I am as a person. It`s my very soul.

[quote]What`s your theory? What are you making?[/quote]
I don`t "make" anything. I use my skills and knowledge to find oil.
0
Reply
Male 5,617
"...and a PhD in Geophysics. Hell, technically, I`m Dr. Davymid..."
Remember that long-assed paper you presented so they`d give you that "D" in "PhD?"
Not "technically." You ARE "Dr. Davymid." It`s a matter of your making people CALL YOU "Dr. Davymid" which will happen after you FEEL like a "Dr. Davymid" which, itself, will probably be right after you figure out what it is you wish to do with/for/about said rocks. Do you even like geology?

What`s your theory? What are you making?
0
Reply
Male 12,138
[quote]I`ve always hated how you were labeled as "smart" for getting a college degree. Having a college degree just means you have the ability to study and pass an exam. I was one of the rare members of Mensa who dropped out of high school.[/quote]
Excellent point. I myself have a degree (First Class Honours with Distinction) in Geology, and a PhD in Geophysics. Hell, technically, I`m Dr. Davymid. People assume that that proves I`m extremely intelligent. In reality, all it proves is, that I know a lot about rocks.
0
Reply
Male 15,832
The single worst thing about public education (with, perhaps, the exception of teachers` unions) is age grouping. Can anything be more unlike the real world?

"So, it`s your first day on the job, is it?"

"Yes."

"How old are you?"

"37."

"Let`s see, the 37-year-olds are all in room 208."

"What are they all doing in there?"

"Ahh...let me see...35, 36, 37, here we are -- logistics. The 37-year-olds are all doing logistics."

"But I`m an electrical engineer."

"Engineer, huh? Well...let`s have a look here...ah, the 34-year-olds are doing electrical engineering, so it looks like you missed that by 3 years. Don`t worry, though. The 43-year-olds are doing mechanical engineering, so if you can just hang in for another 6 years, you should be just fine."
0
Reply
Female 165
That was a very fast 11 minutes. O-O

A+
0
Reply
Male 768
These are always my favorite posts.
0
Reply
Male 1,548
He made some interesting points, but his thesis was off. It is true that we are stuck in an industrial age system of education, but that`s already beginning to change due to the influx of technology. The problem is, he doesn`t understand the lateral thinking model. There`s only one right answer to every meaningful question. Lateral thinking comes in when you can find more than one path to that answer. Lateral thinking is more commonly known nowadays as a "hacker`s mindset" because that`s what kids who can think in this way well end up doing because they have no other avenue to exercise this skill.

I really disagree with the whole "things should be less standardized" point because that`s when you get people being taught creationism in school. What we need is standardization at a younger age, so people don`t get disillusioned by everything they learn in elementary school being lies.
0
Reply
Male 3,076
nice post i wasn`t bored at all!
0
Reply
Male 17,512
Stelly you are onto something there, Today`s `apprenticeships` are actually now formed in technical schools. Tech schools have been on a study rise since the 1980`s, Instead of degrees they give out `certifications`. If you`ve ever had to have your new car fixed, It was likely a ASE certified mechanic that did it.

A degree looks nice on a resume, But employers want experience more. Employers do not want to teach someone to do their job, They want them to already know how to do it and beyond. They want them to improve their company, Not just do an `adequate` job.
0
Reply
Male 294
I loved that; he is very creative! Also some good info was given.

I can`t believe I actually sat through the entire video without once looking at the time or feeling bored. That is a good video
0
Reply
Male 317
I`ve always hated how you were labeled as "smart" for getting a college degree. Having a college degree just means you have the ability to study and pass an exam. I was one of the rare members of Mensa who dropped out of high school.

I`ve been saying for years that society needs to go back to some sort of apprenticeship type of education.

Pop Quiz: What do they call the guy who partied all throughout college, did just enough to keep from failing out, and barley passed his final exams?


Doctor
0
Reply
Male 1,299
@TokioKoos

The full description was truncated and unfortunately the grammar was not corrected. Sorry.
0
Reply
Male 2,422
Great post. It`s certainly something to think about.
0
Reply
Male 136
i`ve looked at teaching in different capacities as a career. i`m going to have to take this video to my team and show it to them. this is amazing stuff. There wasn`t a word I don`t agree with and i feel like this should be implemented both in the grade school and postsecondary levels
0
Reply
Male 226
that was very good.
0
Reply
Male 85
wait, so this was just a giant iphone app add????
i want that drawing at 10:44 as a tattoo though! hahaha
0
Reply
Male 25,416
Wow, when some one is right they are right!
0
Reply
Female 1,963
Fascinating stuff. It really does make very little sense to have children separated into age groups, when age says very little about what you`re good at and what kind of learner you are. Cool animation as well.

I don`t think, though, that any psychologists are debating the very existence of ADHD. It is almost certainly overdiagnosed and overmedicated, but it is definitely a real condition. It`s highly hereditary, and is reflected in physical brain structure.
0
Reply
Female 55
@TokioKoos It says "...Ken Robinson, world-renowned education and creativity expert..." He is an education expert. Not education.
0
Reply
Male 2,553
>NoArms
Agreed, but it is very intriguing. ^^
0
Reply
Female 2,674
I loved this. I love this guy`s voice. Sexy, smooth and smart. I could listen to him all day long.

If I only had my Focusin...
0
Reply
Male 1,237
Wow. Even though it is very easy to do so with videos like this, featuring the epitome of an amiable voice, I definitely agree with what he`s saying..
0
Reply
Male 2,513
I don`t know which is better.
The speech or the awesome whiteboard work.
0
Reply
Male 4,547
This is excellent.
0
Reply
Male 75
Saw this a few days ago. Really interesting, great animation
I seem to be 3-5 days ahead of 60% of IAB`s content at the moment. Really odd.
0
Reply
Female 412
`Ken Robinson, world renowned education and expert`. Wow, I had no idea it was possible to BE education nowadays... *eyeroll*
0
Reply
Male 295
Very interesting! I love this sort of video.
0
Reply
Male 1,222
Great, i learned a couple of things
0
Reply
Male 196
Pretty interesting. I feel like I share some of the same ideas,a s a teacher myself, but I`m a little fuzzy on his ideas of implementation.
0
Reply
Female 2,120
Great! The education system (at least in my area) sucks quite a bit right now.

Can we buy these in poster form somewhere or what?
0
Reply
Male 1,299
Link: Changing Education Paradigms [Rate Link] - A clever adaptation of a speech given by Sir Ken Robinson, world-renowned education and expert.
0
Reply