Symphony of Science: The Unbroken Thread

Submitted by: Brassbull 7 years ago in Science

Carl Sagan, Jane Goodall, and David Attenborough jam out about evolution in this 4th installment of the Symphony series.
There are 50 comments:
Male 548
this video has some fantastic imagery.
0
Reply
Male 773
SAGAN SOUNDS LIKE ERNIE! damn i love sesame street.
0
Reply
Male 915
WUZZIE!
0
Reply
Male 5,194
Damn but I will be glad when "autotune" pukes out its last ugly note and dies once and for all.
0
Reply
Female 1,283
Is that one of the spammers? *Pokes with a stick*
0
Reply
Female 1,283
Hmm...I see, LazyMe XD
0
Reply
Male 49
but ps! as i forgot to add in my previous post.. religions may challenge our minds in different ways that perhaps science cannot, so maybe I was abit harsh claiming that religions are "dumbing" us down =D
0
Reply
Male 49
to be fair we do not really know how it all began. The big bang theory suggests that something happened some 13,7 billion years ago, but what was going on before that? If anything? Perhaps the big-bang took place in an already excisting universe? Nobody knows =) Even so, the big bang theory is the best theory we have, and it is most compatible with the observations we make today.

Claiming a god did this, and a god did that is not really challenging our intellects, it forces us to think inside a box where there are only two possible outcomes, "there is a higher power, or there is not."

Science is a work in progress while religious ideas are based on a script already cut in stone.
0
Reply
Male 2,220
"I believe in guided evolution. I mean the universe is so perfectly tuned for life that it couldnt be a coincidence. And ive read that its not just life but matter itself. If anything were slightly different in the big bang the universe as we know it would not exist."

..and we wouldn`t know about it.

You`re like a puddle of water that is impressed because the shape of the hole you`re in fits you exactly.

Anyway, if you roll with big oscillation theory, then there has been an infinite number of universes preceeding this one, any of which may or may not have given rise to life.
0
Reply
Male 8,302
> LazyMe484
> Hey IAB, can you get rid of all the spammers?

You wouldn`t believe how many posts from that frakkin shoebot get deleted every day. The average time they stay up in about 4 minutes, which isn`t a bad job for 12 or so people spread around the world.

That said, I`m FRAKKIN sick of them myself, so if they don`t stop real soon, I`m gonna write a spambot that will make them sorry they ever logged here in the first place.
0
Reply
Male 15,832
It would be so much better without Autotune. >-(
0
Reply
Male 3,296
i love ya almightybob and btw this sounds like vince with the chopper remix
0
Reply
Male 10,440
@ Skreshavik > I`m arrogant and my standards are high.
0
Reply
Female 1,283
[quote]Hey IAB, can you get rid of all the spammers? If you`re too lazy to do it yourself make more mods to do it for you.[/quote]

Dude, you`re more than welcome to come to the Bad Company 2 forums. Spam up the freakin` arse B-|
Oh, and no mod support to delete all that /b/ crap. I`ll sure as hell take the IAB mods any day, because they are the best I`ve seen.
0
Reply
Male 4,290
[quote]God doesn`t test faith.[/quote]
BZZZZT. Wrong answer.

Genesis 22:1-24. God tests Abraham`s faith by asking him to sacrifice his son Isaac.

The entire Book of Job is God testing Job`s faith by utterly destroying everything good in Job`s life.
0
Reply
Female 474
i love these videos!!! moar plz!!
0
Reply
Male 9
Lotsa plastic muscle here...ruber dancer
0
Reply
Male 10,440
Hey IAB, can you get rid of all the spammers? If you`re too lazy to do it yourself make more mods to do it for you.
0
Reply
Male 10,440
2:19 OM NOM NOM NOM!!!

nice video. Brings a smile to my face.
0
Reply
Male 25,416
learning is fun!
0
Reply
Male 1,610
Angilion - i guess just cause they can. it was interesting to me that you could make discourse into music like this but auto-tune can go die now.
0
Reply
Male 12,365
[quote]They are crap, Just because they stuffed their voices through auto-tune and set it to music doesn`t make them cool or well done.[/quote]

I like the idea of these videos, but stuffing the voices through autotune to distort them gets on my tits. Why do it?
0
Reply
Male 12,365
[quote]oooohhhh... this is so good at explaining evolution, but why dont they ever say how the sea came about? or the planet the sea is in?

everyone seems so sure of evolution, and it seems so convincing in this video... why does noone ever start from the beginning? [/quote]

i) It`s a different theory. Evolution is about the *development* of life, not how the first life started. Evolution doesn`t start at the beginning in the sense you refer to. Planetary formation is another theory again. Planetary development yet another. Scientists generally try to not confuse different things.

ii) There is less compelling evidence for some of the other stuff, particularly the beginning of life. It`s hard to find evidence for something that happened billions of years ago and has not happened since. Scientists generally try to not assume that a well supported theory automatically validates a less supported one.
0
Reply
Male 138
Im not afraid to admit that I find anything regarding life and evolution fascinating and very interesting. It`s a very complex system to study, the beauty of life.

However, I`m also not afraid to admit that I am a Christian, and a very devout believer in God`s Word. Sometimes I can only think the complexity of life itself and the beauty that it holds only holds God`s word to be more true.
0
Reply
Male 12,365
[quote]I believe in guided evolution. I mean the universe is so perfectly tuned for life that it couldnt be a coincidence. And ive read that its not just life but matter itself. If anything were slightly different in the big bang the universe as we know it would not exist.[/quote]

And then we wouldn`t exist to talk about it. You`re mistaking effect for cause. You`re also doing the "god of the gaps" thing - creating a god or gods to stand in for your own ignorance. "I don`t know how it happened, therefore god did it". I don`t know how it happened either, but I`m OK with admitting that.
0
Reply
Male 3
@Imadude
ever heard of the anthropic principle?
What you are referring to is the formation of stars, because as far as we know life would be impossible without stars (and if some universal constants were a bit off stars wouldn`t form).
A lack of an explanation does not mean `god did it`
you are simply making the same mistake humans have made for thousands of years:

ancient egyptian looking at sun:
"What is that shiney thing in the sky? It must be god, because I can think of no other explanation"
0
Reply
Male 716
Jane Goodal`s use of the word "wuzzie" shall now make it acceptable speech. I, for one, plan to implement this word immediantly.
0
Reply
Male 94
LOL Carl Sagan sounds like Kermit the frog.

I believe in guided evolution. I mean the universe is so perfectly tuned for life that it couldnt be a coincidence. And ive read that its not just life but matter itself. If anything were slightly different in the big bang the universe as we know it would not exist.
0
Reply
Male 695
Goddammit! I hate autotune! I`d rather just turn off the sound and watch the subtitles.
0
Reply
Male 286
@greagpethers

This is whats wrong with anti evoultionists. You fail to see that evoultion is not how life started. Notice i said life not planet not seas but life. ITs not a idea of how life started but how it has came to be.

Also if you take 2 seconds you would realize there are also a lot of ideas on how the planet started(such as asteroids steadily colliding and collecting/fusing together from when they impact till they formed the inner rocky planets.)(This idea is why people believe if it wasn`t for Jupiter gravitational influence there would be a 4th rocky planet where the asteroid belt is. But its gravity didn`t allow those planetesimals to form into a planet.) as well as how water came to be on the earth. But these elements are NOT covered in evolution.
0
Reply
Male 17,512
[quote]These are always so cool and well done[/quote]

They are crap, Just because they stuffed their voices through auto-tune and set it to music doesn`t make them cool or well done.

:facepalm:
0
Reply
Male 205
kenisaim: "@auburnjunky - The reason Christians dont believe that is because they believe in the bible. And the bible doesn`t support your idea."

There are some 2 billion christians in over 100 churches. Very few of them take the bible literally. It isn`t considered dogma for most of them.
0
Reply
Male 22
@auburnjunky - The reason Christians dont believe that is because they believe in the bible. And the bible doesn`t support your idea.
0
Reply
Male 271
@brassbull

thanks. will give that a go.
0
Reply
Male 1,931
Faith is the belief in something without evidence. I for one, am not so arrogant to believe in something and protest that belief unto others without evidence.
0
Reply
Male 205
greggpethers: `"it began in the sea, some 3000 million years ago".

oooohhhh... this is so good at explaining evolution`

Actually, it isn`t. Everything from the first prokaryotes to the now living species is reasonably well explained by evolution.
The beginning of life isn`t. (And since it`s not
a process of evolving from one form to another, it`s not part of evolution theory.)
There are some theories about how life began, but we really don`t know yet. That makes it more exciting to me - science in progress.
0
Reply
Male 1,610
@Gregpethers - The video here is simply a compilation or segments from a documentary which was put through a vocoder so make it melodic. It was not meant to give a comprehensive explanation of evolution. If you want to learn more about this is a great site to visit: http://www.pbs.org/ wgbh/evolution/darwin/
- minus the space.
0
Reply
Male 10,339
God doesn`t test faith.

I have faith there is a God.

I also have faith that 2 billion years ago He set into motion events that have shaped the world into what it is today.

EVOLUTION is real. It is natural. God started the ball rolling, and he let it roll. A few times, he intervenes in evolution (eyes, brain development, complex evolution) but for the most part, he put us (all living things) here to be free and that`s exactly what he is doing.

I wish more Christians felt this way, but some of them are just close minded/oblivious to facts.
0
Reply
Male 271
i sort of agree with you,WolfStar, but then i sort of dont too.

i can honestly say that evolution is obviously happening, and that the vid is a pretty cool explanation of it.

but when it says "it began in the sea, some 3000 million years ago" it just makes me wonder what did? you know... like the whole chain of life is connected by a single thread... but then, so is everything that came before it. you see what i mean?

i just wish that part was as well explained and logical.
0
Reply
Female 455
`why does noone ever start from the beginning?`

They do, but in different programmes. There are plenty of clips/websites/books out there explaining how the Earth and the seas formed, but it`s a different subject to that of evolution.
0
Reply
Male 4,014
my god.
0
Reply
Male 4,014
"why dont they ever say how the sea came about?"

A theory says H2O was carried here on frozen asteroids, and the particularities of earths magnetic field and climate were such that the H2O didn`t boil away into space. There are probably other theories as well.

What I cannot accept is flat denial of evolutionary process.

How can one explain finding the bones of animals long since dead, yet who bear striking - though different - similarities to animals I find today? I don`t accept that God planted fossils to test my faith. I think it more likely an animal long ago died in soil conditions that preserved the outline of his bones.

Occam`s razor - the simplest explination is most likely correct. I CAN FOSSILIZE SOMETHING RIGHT NOW IN A SIMPLE EXPERIMENT.

Its reasonable fossils happened in the past. Far more reasonable than god did it.

However, I also have proof that some "rules" govern existence, and therein lies
0
Reply
Female 4,039
Can it be any louder!! I think my eardrum is bleeding.
0
Reply
Male 2,220
The earth was grown from dust and comets brought water. Life formed. Whats difficult about that?
0
Reply
Male 41
Wuzzy?
0
Reply
Male 4,014
I`m going to admit it - if someone tells me they don`t believe in evolution, I dismiss them outright. You can`t argue with the willfully ignorant.


0
Reply
Male 271
"it began in the sea, some 3000 million years ago".

oooohhhh... this is so good at explaining evolution, but why dont they ever say how the sea came about? or the planet the sea is in?

everyone seems so sure of evolution, and it seems so convincing in this video... why does noone ever start from the beginning?

frustrating!
0
Reply
Male 15,510
These are always so cool and well done, my favorite one is We are all connected
0
Reply
Male 1,929
Sweeeeeeeeet
0
Reply
Male 1,610
Link: Symphony of Science: The Unbroken Thread [Rate Link] - Carl Sagan, Jane Goodall, and David Attenborough jam out about evolution in this 4th installment of the Symphony series.
0
Reply