Puppy Toss

Submitted by: KoalaMeatPie 9 years ago in Weird
/media/17368_puppytoss.flv
What the f--- !? Hopefully this is Photoshopped. Warning: possibly upsetting footage.
There are 334 comments:
Male 13
I realize innocent civilians are dying and that is much much more of an important issue/problem, but this is actually filmed by these soldiers, and the worst thing is that they actually seem to enjoy doing it.

Just another step in the fight against terrorism I suppose. For all we know that dog could have been on the terrorist suspect list.
0
Reply
Female 1
This is faked, you all know that, right? When the guy `tosses` the puppy, it`s spinning is wrong. When the puppy `hits the ground,` it just disappears, it doesn`t even actually land.
But in this case, I am on the side of who gives a f***. I am tired of seeing everyone freak out over a puppy when their own race is in need. Everyone is always donating to organizations that help animals when there are at least 20 kids starving in my small school who`s town has less than 15K people. Now, don`t get me wrong, I have nothing against saving animals. I like no-kill shelters and disagree with animal abuse. I have 3 dogs and a rat, and I would never hurt them and honestly couldn`t see anyone hurting animals like them. Now, don`t think me black-hearted to say that this video doesn`t make me fall into an emotional wreck, just think that there are children caught in the war who`s parents died and are now starving to death while trying to take care of their siblings.
0
Reply
Male 2
I`m not saying it should be acceptable to kill puppies for fun, but we should pay more mind to other humans in my mind.
0
Reply
Male 2
Why does everybody always freak out over stuff like this? One little puppy gets thrown off a cliff and you all poo your pants and write about how you want to pour salt in someone`s open wounds; but does anyone say any such things about the countless civilians suffering worse fates? You might find one or two comments with psychotic disturbing messages close to the ones found here. Don`t you think we should drop the rights and wrongs of Disney already?
0
Reply
Female 227
ANIMALS ARE BETTER THAN PEOPLE!! THEY THINK THEY`RE SOOOO COOL WAIT TILL I SEE ONE OF THEM!!!!!!!!I`L KILL THEM!!!!!!!!!!!BITING OFF SNAKE HEADS, THROWING PUPPIES OFF CLIFFS,(wait who are they fighting with?) well whoever they are,, just throw them in fudgeing jail and shoot them or rip theyre skin off and puor salt on them!!THAT`LL MAKE THEM PAAAAAYYY!!!!
0
Reply
Male 2
Hey SnoopDawg................you JACKASS.....these morons signed up (if they can write) all by themselves for the service....probably cause they`re TOO STUPID to get in college. They thought they`d get free school and benefits for live and now they have to go to war.....OH WELL!!! Stop defending the morons!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
0
Reply
Male 2
This guy is a coward punk and so is the guy with him!!!! Two dumbass punks who are in the service for the free education and benefits only!!! Their parents should be real proud of the CROWARDS they raised..............the parents are probably losers too!!!!! Remember the apple doesn`t fall too far from the tree!!! Would love to meet both these COWARDS!!!
0
Reply
Female 348
god i am soo angry
0
Reply
Female 348
what a disgusting excuse for a man i hope he f*cking dies or gets thrown off a cliff that is just mindless and psychotic appalling behavior that puppy did not deserve it
0
Reply
Male 374
i hope the taliban blow his drating brains out
0
Reply
Female 75
WHAT THE drat!!!!! drating dickheads!, how sick are they? throwing a godamn puppy that looks not even 2 weeks old off a drating cliff!, people like that deserve to drating die!!! DX >_<
0
Reply
Female 5
i hope that drater dies!!! WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT!!! WHAT A dratING BASTARD!!! I`M SO ANGRY AND UPSET!!!! non-nice individual....AMERICAN non-nice individual!!!! I DON`T KNOW ANY OTHER HUMAN BEING THAT WOULD DO THAT TO AN ANIMAL!!!!! BASTARD!!!!! I WANT THAT GUY DEAD!!!!!!!!!
0
Reply
Female 582
the only reason i`m mad is becuase he did it for fun. Thats cruel. a war is totally different, and so is eating animals. laughing after you kill something is wrong on so many levels
0
Reply
Female 870
This is for all our soldiers overseas; you wonder why we don`t support our troops. You guys are over in the Middle East, completely lawless, living every dark fantasy you`ve got and you think you are coming home to a proud country?? drat you guys. The war was stupid from the beginning and no one is being forced to fight. Just call a spade a spade, bush is an non-nice individual, put down your guns and go home. Pricks.
0
Reply
Female 187
and its my opinion that anyone in the military. Drafted or joining by choice is a hero.
0
Reply
Male 91
People have such blind double standards. When the US dropped the A-bombs in WWII, over 100,000 innocent civilians lost their lives... but we were `heros`. Countless cows are slaughtered daily to make your hamburgers. But this soldier, who is serving his country, possibly including the stress and risk of regular life-and-death combat, kills a puppy, and people are outraged. A life is a life, you can`t munch on your McDonald`s and hate the puppy-killer too. At least be consistent.
0
Reply
Female 69
cock.
0
Reply
Female 187
....you and I have a different view of what a hero is.
I believe that someone who risks his life for the safety or life of another is a hero.
0
Reply
Female 27
"well i saw this on the local paper another day.
apparently they think that people care more about the puppy than the iraqi or soldiers dying in iraq"

Pardon but its true what Mani Jac says. Sure these people are dying but to kill a dog just for the fun of it deserves outrage. Plus people like him deserve to die. . .)

0
Reply
Female 407
That was retarded on so many drating levels...its not even funny.
0
Reply
Male 2,605
It doesn`t matter to me how significant the financial incentive is to join, the fact is that there is one. What you are saying is that the man is a hero on the sole premise that he joined the military. Does that, in your opinion, render less heroic everyone who was drafted to join the military?

One isn`t a hero for joining the military willingly. Brave, perhaps, but not heroic. That is expressed in deeds and has always been since the time of the Greeks. I haven`t seen this man commit any particularly heroic acts, but I did see him unnecessarily kill a defenseless puppy. Call him a hero if you wish, but don`t dare wonder why the US and people in it are assumed to have a lesser moral compass than the rest of the world.

0
Reply
Female 700
someone blow his ass up... NOW!
0
Reply
Female 187
"Signing up for the military with the likely promise of future financial gain and other benefits tends to render the act of signing up significantly less heroic"

there are not that many financial benifits. Especially for enlisted men. There`s health care and teh GI bill but enlisted people don`t get rich off of the military.

Going to war doesn`t make you a hero. What makes him a hero is that he signed his life away for at least six years. he can be sent anywhere in the world at a moment`s notice. He was suddenly out fighting for me and for you.

In my book that makes him a hero.

and let`s not talk about the politics behind the war. We disagree and we will always disagree. He may disagree with me, but he obeyed his orders and did as he had to do. The reasons behind the war are moot.

0
Reply
Female 43
You know, going to war doesn`t make you a hero just like that. Specially a pointless war like Iraq. I reckon why would anyone want to be a hero. I mean, you may want to help people, to do good, to do your best and be kind to your fellow man. If you do all those things you still may not be considered a hero. There`s nothing heroic about this stupid, petty war.

0
Reply
Male 2,605
"Puppy or not he`s still a hero."

Signing up for the military with the likely promise of future financial gain and other benefits tends to render the act of signing up significantly less heroic. Besides that, you`ve no proof he did anything heroic, puppy or no. I`m much more comfortable condemning him for what is easily seen\witnessed\verifiable versus revering him for what is not.

0
Reply
Female 1,398
I love how people care more about some dog than people over there dying. I also love how this gets the news, but not the slaughter of Jewish children by muslims just because they went to a religious school.
0
Reply
Female 15
poor puppy
0
Reply
Female 15
that guy will some how,"burn to death"... i hope
0
Reply
Female 15
of corse, the person who posted this was, "KoalaMeatPie" I-(
0
Reply
Male 98
fake
0
Reply
Male 944
hes fighitng for us let him chillll maaaaaan...risked his life and stuff, give da man a break. go to pets mart if u wanna dog
0
Reply
Female 679
Oh my god thats so shocking :|
I really hope they burn to death
I feel so bad for that puppy
0
Reply
Female 187
Puppy or not he`s still a hero.
0
Reply
Female 187
whether he`s sorry or not harrassing him isn`t going to do anything. It won`t bring the puppy back, it won`t help anything. Leave him alone. Please.
0
Reply
Male 2,605
"And this is obvious that is fake."

Yes, primetimekin, because you`ve shown exemplar aptitude in the past in distinguishing that which is fake and fabricated from that which is real and factual. Good job.

I`m not sure I care whether he is sorry in hindsight about the animal. It`s dead and he`s not and he should be responsible for his actions. Deplorable.

0
Reply
Female 18
You would have to have a good grip and a good throwing arm to throw a puppy that far. besides where di d they get a dog like that over there the screams seem too loud to be so far away and it just stops once it goes over the edge idk but it makes me sick. but then again im sure that dog would have gotten blown up someday eventually over there
0
Reply
Male 550
It`s REAL as he admitted it.
Here`s the link to his MySpace cache.

Here`s a direct quote:
I want to clear somethings up before tomarrow. This might be hard to believe but I am sorry about the dog. At the time I just really didn`t care. When you are constantly under fire sometimes people develope a different sence of humor than what others are used to. That video was from over a year ago and i dont know who put it out there but it wasn`t me. It has been a real hard day. I don`t know how they got my information but someone got all my information and i had to disconnect my parents and my womans phone. not to mention i had to redo my myspace because it got hacked. I just want this to end.

0
Reply
Female 187
anyone ever get those humane sticky traps for mice? Once they`re on the sticky you take them outside and squish them with your feet or throw the tape violently on the ground to kill the mouse.
people still sometimes drown puppies and kittens.

Burn in hell?
Hot knife to eye?
that`s a bit much don`t you think?

I`m not saying I like it, but only that you guys are a little bit crazy for freaking out this much.

0
Reply
Female 45
they`re bastards, what did that puppy do to them
0
Reply
Male 488
how could they throw that poor puppy off a CUH-LIFF!
0
Reply
Male 19
His name David Motari. Look him up on myspace, add him as a friend, cuss him out, then delete him from existance. i did and boy did it feel good.

That guy should burn in the deepest pits of Hell

0
Reply
Male 7,933
ttsec thank you for clearing it up. I agree with you on the double standard to an extent. Rodents are pest at times and extermination is often (more) useful. But I get your point.

And this is obvious that is fake. Unless you have never seen a dog in your life and dont know about its reaction then it should be an obvious fake.

This video goes against the Doppler Effect, the dog has no motion, and notice how the camera man avoids touching the dog. If it were a real and alive dog, it would be squirming or atleast have its eyes open or follow the laws of the doppler effect. If it was a already dead dog it would be less stiff or rotten.
Its a doll. fake.

0
Reply
Female 1,572
.....:/
0
Reply
Male 242
i hope this guy rots in hell
0
Reply
Male 666
^ Actually, the marine looks pretty healthy to me. Otherwise he wouldn`t make such a lean mean killing machine. The puppy on the other hand...not so healthy. 5uX0rz 40r 73h d09z!
0
Reply
Male 244
why the drat would any cornuto upload this? i do not give a poo if it is photoshopped or not it is still sick.
0
Reply
Female 583
I don`t think there is any point in hoping that puppy is ok. It was flung pretty far. |-(
0
Reply
Male 944
^ yeaaaaaah u need to go lie down or somethin
0
Reply
Female 8
I want to slowly torture those guys and then leave them somewhere to be eaten alive by wild animals..Yeah that sounds good..
0
Reply
Male 944
@ EstiloPanama

....i like ur avatar pic

0
Reply
Male 944
@overgamer435 "speff.....wtf? They could`ve killed the poor thing!"

um yeah im sure the THING is dead...just saying...it went off a cliff...hehe

0
Reply
Male 944
alright if its fake awome, but im sure its not, if its not fake, get over it worse things happen, if you don like it then dont whatch or talk about it, there was a warning message. go eat cake or somethin life sucks anyway
0
Reply
Female 58
OG435- everyone seemed to be saying `OMG POOR PUPPY`
just wanted to see the response to someone who was on the other side and found it funny.
Obviously bad then aye =D?

They have a point though, the whole `everyone cares about puppies and not people`, but he`s went about proving it the wrong way, he could have just SAID it lul.

0
Reply
Male 203
speff.....wtf? They could`ve killed the poor thing!
0
Reply
Female 58
lmao @ puppy tosser too, aw man this made my day ahahaha
0
Reply
Female 58
lmfao, it just flew all the way past
ahahahahaha
0
Reply
Male 203
bastards.
0
Reply
Male 60
THIS GUY IS A dratING MORON.

I WANT TO GET A KNIFE AND PUT IT INTO HOT COALS FOR AN HOUR AND STAB IT INTO HIS EYE AND HOLD IT THERE UNTIL HE DIES! WHAT A dratFACE!

0
Reply
Male 292
T-T
0
Reply
Female 43
Anyways you look at it the guy is sick. That`s the bottom line. Well, after torturing prisoners you can pretty much expect anything from the U.S military. As you can expect anything from people at war. But none of this makes this guy any less sick. People who enjoy killing anything as much as that should not be allowed near a gun.

0
Reply
Male 713
Ever read the selfish gene? Its cool
0
Reply
Male 666
^ You read that too? Nice. I remember writing a paper on Orcas including making a 3D model of an Orca and it`s biological structures. That`s how I know the Orca example.

I think animals and humans have distinct differences. This is why I don`t think animals are capable of love. I think they`re capable of attachment and showing and wanting care, but not love. I think love includes complete self-sacrifice, even for a total stranger, without considering yourself or genetic perpetuation. On the other hand, anything an animal does, even those that are commonly seen as love, can be explained by genetic perpetuation, which is inherently selfish, and therefore cannot qualify as love.

0
Reply
Male 550
Here`s the Wikipedia entry to ttsec`s post.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orca#_ref-F...

Of course, we can`t compare humans and animals. Humans are sentient, and most animals are not.

0
Reply
Male 666
applejaqs, I`ll give you an example:

Scientists have never observed Resident Orcas to eat mammals, they`ve only seen them eat fish, but Resident Orcas have often been witnessed killing and harassing seals and porpoises for apparently no reason. They don`t eat them. They just kill them and play around with their dead or half-dead bodies, or kill them by playing around with them. Clearly, they are killing for fun.

0
Reply
Male 1
Just be glad they didn`t video tape me raping your mother.
0
Reply
Female 252
Better be fake nothing gives him the right to kill an innocent animal, if he has to kill something so badly he can do his job and kill the enemy!
0
Reply
Male 23
course there are tons of video editing programs out there too.
0
Reply
Male 23
you can so photoshop video files. it would just take forever to photoshop every frame..
0
Reply
Female 1,492
WTF!!! BASTARD!!!
0
Reply
Male 2,216
One sec... isnt this a repost of the video that`s about 3 links back?
0
Reply
Male 2,216
You can`t Photoshop video ffs. The name is a give away.
0
Reply
Male 550
I have some points to make:
1) People are enraged over the puppy-killing because it`s WEAK and HELPLESS, which is different from other animals such as rodents or sharks which are vicious by nature. If it`s an adult dog, the reaction would`ve been very different.
2) Those who think people are valuing a puppy`s life more than a human life is mistaken. We do not see documented killings of innocent civilians on the internet because it`s banned in most countries, hence we can`t feel the pain and suffering they`re going through prior to, or during their death. If it`s an infant being thrown off the cliff, the internet would no doubt, asplode.
3) People who wish that Marine dead don`t really mean it. It`s how they express themselves on the internet, and it`s a typical behavioral response. I`m sure if they meet face to face the worst that could happen is a fistfight.
4) People are having a very hard to determine whether it`s real or fake, so stop believing it`s obvious to anyone.
0
Reply
Female 29
alright for those of you who think that animals kill out of fun... and its scientificly proven... then prove it to me. and ttsec ^ I kill all animals I want out of survival. what the hell is that suppose to mean? yeah well prove to me that you know what your talking about cuz you are just sayin a bunch of shi*. i`ve done my research for many years and you clearly have no clue what you`re talking about. fu** yall
0
Reply
Male 80
i call fake, looked like a stuffed animal, but who knows the marines are egotistical dickheads like that anyways the armys better
0
Reply
Female 187
time will probably tell.
0
Reply
Male 9,305
I did not watch the video. I am sure it will upset me. Then I am sure I will become emotional and violent.

Me becoming violent is not a positive thing...

0
Reply
Male 3
Oh, man, that`s just...mean. I don`t think that was photoshopped.
0
Reply
Male 666
Also, if you say an animal can love, then you must also say that an animal can hate and be atrocious. If animals are capable of human emotions, then they are capable of both the good and bad ones. Saying animals can only have the good ones is a illogical and another double standard.
0
Reply
Male 666
Back to double standard on animals:

It annoys me when people love household pets but don`t mind killing some possum or rodent. This is a double standard. Your ideology should be the same towards all animals. Saying a puppy has more value of life than a shark is a double standard, and is a very shallow statement/belief.

0
Reply
Male 666
But the sound is pretty clear. And it`s pretty clear the sound is not following the Doppler Effect.
0
Reply
Female 187
the video is grainy, The dog could be real or fake or dead. I am only saying that there is no real proof for either. Just a lot of speculation.
0
Reply
Male 666
BroadwayLove, if the dog is real, how do you explain the physics-defying puppy sounds? Are you saying this puppy is magical and can defy physics?
0
Reply
Male 126
loool!!
0
Reply
Male 666
primetimekin, I don`t really want to kill all household pets. I was just emphasizing the double standard given to household pets and how I can use that same line of thinking to make it sound logical that all household pets should be killed.

I have household pets myself, and I`m not against animals. However, I am against double standards.

People already said the video is still atrocious even if the puppy is dead/faked, but if it was a dead possum, people would care a lot less. This is the double standard I`m talking about. This is what I`m against.

Also people who claim animals can have human emotions and can love, but yet deny any possibility they can hate. That is double standard also, and also what I`m against.

I`m not against animals.

0
Reply
Female 187
puppies go limp when they are held by the neck. The dog could be real.
0
Reply
Male 7,933
THE DOG IS FAKE!!!! Its looks stuffed. If it was an already dead dog the only way it would remain as motionless is if it was stuffed.

Yes animals do kill each other, same as humans. Should we kill all household pets like ttsec says, no. The Vets wont then become human doctors and that takes away from the economy. Good in theory but it wont work in practice.

People who enlist in the military know about the risk of wars. Its just in their job descriptions. People are forgetting that war causes new jobs (people leave and others have to fill in, making weapons etc.) which was important after Katrina. After Katrina our unemployment stayed relatively low.

And it may seem terrible but wars, famine, genocide, etc, is actually important. by the year 2020 the population would be so high that some countries like El Salvador would need to start purchasing water from other nations. But most importantly ITS NOT A REAL DOG!!!

0
Reply
Male 506
sadface |-( I want to kick that guy`s ass.
0
Reply
Male 51
YOU PEOPLE NEED TO PULL YOUR HEADS OUT OF YOUR ASSES!!! Where is your outrage at what is happening to humans around the world? Where is your outrage at the war atrocities that were posted on Youtube and Liveleek of dead civilians and military being posed in positions (i.e. cigarettes hanging out their mouths, pointing in a certain direction, etc...)or the firefights over in Iraq & Afghanistan? Did you think those were special effects? Do you think those people were extras in a movie?

I love how everybody talks so tough over the internet!! Americans on here saying they would kick this marines ass and kill his family over a dog!!??? YOU PEOPLE ARE A BUNCH OF CUM SOAKED TWATS!!! Talk is cheap.

And as far as you pathetic titty baby punks from outside the US...GO drat YOURSELVES!!!!

0
Reply
Male 437
:-O Holy poop
0
Reply
Female 576
That`s disgusting :/
0
Reply
Male 666
B-Hazard, I think he`s saying that they are not innocent because they have guns. But actually it would be more like tens of thousands not hundreds. He also didn`t state those were the ONLY people who died in Iraq. You assumed he was making an all-encompassing statement yourself.
0
Reply
Male 868
It is true that all (that have weapons) have an opportunity to throw down their weapons surrender - run away etc.It`s not some algebraic transitive property for someone to wrongfully interpret. Is it really hundreds? Are they really innocent? Where`s the data source? Or its that a number arbitraily created to argues a weak statement.
0
Reply
Male 2,958
ahem

"Hundreds of innocent die in iraq? hey they all have a chance to throw down their weapons."

that literally says all of the innocents that die in iraq refuse to put down their guns and pose a threat. I truthfully cannot see any other way it can be taken.

0
Reply
Female 187
Knowelege gained from one person does not compare to the knowelege gained from the treatment of many. Given you as a source or a psychologist who frequently treats those with PTSD I choose the psychologist.
0
Reply
Male 868
BWL - plenty of females in combat these days. Knowledge gained first hand through experience far exceed text book theory. And duke of hazard i did not say justifiable nor every iraqi casualty from the war is an insurgent.. scotty - beam me up!
0
Reply
Female 187
... a good point. Worth thinking about.
0
Reply
Male 2,958
-no not every one- thats why they are called casualties ofwar. But that doesnt mean it was intentional. William Shatner would be ashamed of you using his picture..-

I never said civilian casualties were "intentional", YOU said they were justifiable by self defense.

I mean, an innocent casualty wouldn`t be much of an innocent with a gun in their hands, so how does that work?

0
Reply
Male 868
my point is peopl know right from wrong. Our society makes too many excuses, toomany claims that poor youths ar a product of our society.What eve happened to moral accountability?
0
Reply
Female 187
Argumentatively it gives you very little credibility. In an academic argument you are citable only as an eyewitness or an example. For this subject a psychologist would be cited.

And of course I haven`t taken a life in the service of my country. I`m female after all.

0
Reply
Male 868
The fact that I have had to take life in the service of my country does make give me some credibility. And I still wouldn`t kill a puppy.
0
Reply
Male 666
PTSD is independent of the military. It can exist in many non-military people, and it will cause many behavioral phenomenons, including panic attacks, hallucinations, and sometimes violence.
0
Reply
Female 187
I don`t understand your argument Rogue Knight. The fact that you were in the military makes you no expert. The fact that I have never been to war means very little. Post Traumatic Stress Disorder is known for causing violent behavior in those afflicted by it.
0
Reply
Male 868
Well Michael Vick is being held in the United States Penitentiary at Leavenworth, Kansas....
0
Reply
Male 666
I!
0
Reply
Male 868
Hey broadway love -theres a difference. I was in the military. How many peopl have you killed in the name of liberty. It`s not a helpless puppy. Post Traumatic Stress Disorder- go drink some beer and cry
0
Reply
Male 868
no not every one- thats why they are called casualties ofwar. But that doesnt mean it was intentional. William Shatner would be ashamed of you using his picture..
0
Reply
Male 868
Hey broadway love -theres a difference. I was in the military. How many peopl have you killed in the name of liberty. It`s not a helpless puppy. Post Traumatic Stress Disorder- go drink some beer and cry
0
Reply
Male 2,958
I`m pretty sure no one is going to want to side with someone who thinks every iraqi casualty from the war is an insurgent.
0
Reply
Male 868
Anyone who could harm a helpless animal is a fcking coward. Hundreds of innocent die in iraq?hey they all have a chance to throw down their weapons. We wentover their to help them. Bushel of wheat for a barrelof oil!
0
Reply
Female 187
killing an innocent puppy is awful but keep in mind. These soldiers are dealing with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. They`re not always of the same mindset that you are. I`m not saying that that fives them the right to throw a puppy off of a cliff, but war changes people and changes thier perspective on things. Once you`ve Killed fifty or so people. Once you`ve begun to accept the idea that you have ended fifty lives, a puppy doesn`t seem like that big of a deal.

People didn`t freak out like this over Michael Vick.

0
Reply
Male 868
PS.ttsec is a fcking idiot too! All in favor- say "I"
0
Reply
Male 868
Anyone who could harm a helpless animal is a fcking coward. Hundreds of innocent die in iraq?hey they all have a chance to throw down their weapons. We wentover their to help them. Bushel of wheat for a barrelof oil!
0
Reply
Male 13
I can`t believe the idiots posting here.
Yes, killing a dog isn`t a good thing. But are you people seriously saying we should give out the death penalty for killing a dog? "Yeah, let`s throw HIM off a cliff" Doesn`t this seem a bit extreme to anyon else?
0
Reply
Male 666
My beef is with the double standard given to animals, as if animals are more innocent. If you say animals do what they do out of "nature" or whatever you call it, the same can be said about humans. Humans do it out of human "nature." Ha. Saying that it happens in the wild and because of nature doesn`t make it any better. Humans consider outside nature "wild." I`m sure animals consider human habitats "wild" as well, and consider their own habitats "domestic." It`s all a matter of perspective.
0
Reply
Male 666
^ I kill all animals I want out of survival.

If you don`t know about animals killing each other for fun in nature, then you`re clearly ignorant about animal behavior. It`s been documented that animals also exhibit breedism (racism for humans). The so-called "hate" is just as useless of an emotional attribution made by humans as "love." If animal lovers claim animals can love, I can use the same nonsense logic to say animals can hate. I can also use the same nonsense logic to say animals have moral conscience and therefore can "know better."

0
Reply
Female 36
All I have to say is this video shouldn`t have been posted for any reason, regardless of whether it`s real or fake or real with a dead/fake/edited in puppy. If it`s going to cause controversy, it shouldn`t be posted.

"Life`s not fair you bitch stfu n00b I pwn your ass!!1! There`s gonna be controversy in life so stfu and care for the soldiers more than the puppy!one! We should pwn ALL animals! BWAHAHAHAHA1!forty!one"

There, I said it for you, and I reply with: Blahblahblah, not caring what you think.

Should not. Have been. Posted. I rest my case.

0
Reply
Female 29
"ttsec: animals kill each other for fun all the time, including dogs."
and no, animals dont kill eachother for fun... humans who train them make them kill for fun. i think that you are the one who doesnt know what the hell goes on in nature. yeah, you may have seen animals fight in the wild (example: deer, wolves, elk, bear... any wild animal) this is only because of their nature. maybe you should spend a few weeks out in the wild, you`d learn that some of the stupid stuff you say is not true... then we will all see whos right. humans kill and train to kill... animals do it for survival, and US killing in Iraq is not for survival. it`s because of our weak government and the choices we make. period b_i_t_c_h_s
0
Reply
Female 29
first off ttsec, you would want to kill the rodants, wild animals and barn yard animals considering that they are the ones who carry most of the diseases today. have you heard of a dog or cat carrying a disease producing bacteria around the world? and how do you know that animals hate eachother more than humans do? just because they kill eachother doesnt mean anything, thats why they are considered "animals". they are territorial and live in the wild, thats the only way they know. humans know better.
0
Reply
Male 2,958
-When animals kill, it`s because they need to (i.e. for food). When humans kill, it`s because they want to (i.e. murder, war, etc.).-

lmao. animals murder each other all the time.

babies are eaten by siblings or parents, chimps brutally attack each other over territory, sharks beat dolphins senseless with little intention of eating them afterwards.

how many times has a house cat killed a mouse out of necessity?

0
Reply
Female 744
Hundreds of innocent people die in the Iraq war: Eh
One puppy killed: OUTRAGE!
0
Reply
Female 48
Well unless that puppy happened to be a realistic looking stuffed animal. I doubt it was though x.X
0
Reply
Female 48
I might sound stupid to ask, but how can you photoshop a video?

& Btw, that was horrible. ]:
Hopefully this is `shopped. If it`s even possible /;

0
Reply
Female 14
Everyone who keeps talking about "killing this guy", or "ripping his nuts off", or hoping "he gets shot by one of those terrorists" is just as guilty as he is. Violence is so contagious. Throwing the puppy off the cliff is just as vicious and violent as hoping this Marine dies, whether it be by "those terrorists" (which is such a negative stereotype of the Middle East to begin with) or by you hoping to meet him one day so you can do the deed yourself. Violence is violence no matter who it is directed to.


And also, if the puppy was dead or not, if the video is fake or not, or even if its just a "stupid puppy", the brutality of it is just the same. No one should ever be this sadistic to anything. Living or dead, fake or not, its the principal of the thing. However, I think that it is important that people see this kind of thing so we can all stop living in our bubbles and start to realize that this kind of sh*t goes down everyday,

0
Reply
Male 58
It`s only because it`s a puppy. If it were a raccoon or an opossum, there would be no debate. Of course, that still doesn`t efface the fact that a Marine possibly killed an animal. Yes, an animal - not a defenseless, maimed puppy.
0
Reply
Male 176
[quote]this makes me want to go on a rampage of killing drating marines[/quote]
Go die in a fire
0
Reply
Female 1
I hope one of those iraqi terrorists catch him and cut his friggin head off! SLOWLY! So he feels everything!
0
Reply
Female 14
Soldier decide to go to war fully knowing that they may be killed. An innocent puppy has no choice if a stupid, heartless Marine decides to chuck him off a cliff. Yes, it`s sad that people are dying, but it is even sadder that people are vicious and remorseless to do a thing like that to a helpless creature. This is why trigger-happy war mongers disgust me so f*cking much; He should be locked up and dishonnorably discharged.
0
Reply
Male 21
Just a reminder, this section is for commenting on the videos, not attacking each other. Everyone is entitled to their own views and beliefs.

Persony, I think this is disgusting, and it is videos like these that give everyone a bad opinion of America when only one in a million people would do something like this, whether the puppy is alive or not does not change the brutality of the act.

0
Reply
Male 645
0
Reply
Male 7,933
Media is retarded, they get it wrong all the time, its obviously fake
0
Reply
Male 108
This isn`t fake at all. I saw it on the news just this morning. Maybe I`m a Jesus-freak, liberal hippy... but this is exactly why I can`t stand the marines. They are trained killers. My uncle- who was a marine- told me that it is rare for a marine to enter the military, go to war, and come back human. It`s sad... but this is what America is doing to it`s citizens. They don`t really care... As long as they kill.
0
Reply
Male 7,933
Kill Peta, go ASPCA
0
Reply
Male 666
xoxcassxox, Animals hurt animals all the time. They can love, but the can also hate, and sometimes kill for entertainment purposes only.
0
Reply
Male 99
that was so obviously fake i cannot believe any of you retards believed it
0
Reply
Female 263
Anyone who thinks this is ok obviously doesn`t have a pet they dearly love. Don`t under estimate the love between owner and pet. People hurt people all the time but pets are here souly to love and be loved
0
Reply
Male 666
bloodstone45, animals kill each other for fun all the time, including dogs. And if they were smart enough to make a nuke, they`d use it too. Don`t think they are so innocent just because they aren`t technologically advanced. If you think animals are any more innocent than humans, then you clearly haven`t seen a lot of things that go on in nature. Your knowledge of animal behavior is probably limited to only that of domestic (enslaved) animals, which is definitely not indicative of real animal behavior. You think a dog is innocent, but if given the chance, it`d kill, kill, and kill some more, even if it`s not hungry. You obviously know nothing of animals. Animal lovers often say animals are capable of emotion, such as love and attachment. You know what? I agree, and they`re just as capable of hating and racism (breedism) as much as humans.
0
Reply
Male 3,431
This video really needs not be posted in public. Knowing the act was committed is reason enough to villify the douche that did it. I guarantee that watching this video will not make anyones life better.
0
Reply
Female 179
How the drat can people say that that was funny?!?! That was the MOST horrible thing I have ever seen! How could someone do that?? It`s like throwing a new-born baby off a cliff! I`m disgusted... this is why I hate people
0
Reply
Female 7
Dead or alive (probably dead, it seems to be in a state of rigor mortis), this is a terrible way to treat an animal. Really. I`m more embarrassed than usual to be an American.
ttsec, are you REAL? "Animals kill each other and hate each other more than humans do." What planet do you live on? Have you ever seen dogs wage nuclear war against each other? When animals kill, it`s because they need to (i.e. for food). When humans kill, it`s because they want to (i.e. murder, war, etc.).
0
Reply
Male 1,149
The dog that is, it`s clearly not real.
0
Reply
Male 1,149
Sure looks fake.
0
Reply
Male 63
Lol it`s not I`m for cruelty against animals, but I really laughed watching this! I`m against animal rights... Why caring about a dumb dog when human beings are suffering over the world?
0
Reply
Female 1,407
He might as well throw a infant, that A-hole!>-(
0
Reply
Female 56
I ignored the warning =[

*sobs*

0
Reply
Female 2,695
ohmygod. i think i`m going to cry.
0
Reply
Male 943
stupid drating piece of poo, this makes me want to go on a rampage of killing drating marines, you think your life is worth more than a dog? Well it won`t be when I take it from you. Vile disgusting piece of poo, I hope you die
0
Reply
Male 666
bri-chees06, I don`t want to destroy all animals, just dogs and cats. I`m using the same type of double standard that so-called animal lovers use who couldn`t care less about humans.

Animals kill each other and hate each other more than humans do. So happy living in your animal only world.

0
Reply
Male 7,933
bri-cheese What are you talking about? Animals have wars. A lot.
0
Reply
Female 21
ttsec your talkin out your hole.... animals are just as important to this world as humans are...maybe even more so... my suggestion would be drat civilisation... id rather live with animals than a bunch of sick freaks... at least then there would be no war... no superficiality... the list goes on... who cares about ppl.. its ppl who are the danger... that vid is a prime example... real or fake im sure its happened somewhere before
0
Reply
Female 21
why is iab nicing up my msg...that F u c k was an
A S S H O L E
0
Reply
Female 21
This actually makes me feel sick.... if i ever met this drated up bastard.. oh man... id cut his fudgeen dick off and shove it down his neck making him choke until he lost conciousness.. then id wake him up and slash lil cuts all over his body and pour vinegar and salt all over him... then he`d know how it feels to be helpless and under the control of someone sick... non-nice individual
0
Reply
Male 7,933
PHOTOSHOPPED- The Shopping(editing) of Photos.

If this was real (how most of you are claiming) what is a puppy doing in the middle of the dessert? Why isn`t it moving? Does this video disprove the Doppler Effect?

0
Reply
Female 9
That was really sad- I hope it was photoshopped
0
Reply
Female 48
FAKE. FAKE. FAKE.
0
Reply
Female 2,196
that guy sucks theres no reason for throwing the puppy
0
Reply
Male 55
``you`re mean Motari``......sadly yes. but to fight in mean wars you need mean people. ugly fact but there you go.
0
Reply
Male 666
^ Ha ha, a booby trapped puppy. Probably won`t be the first time it`s happened.
0
Reply
Male 741
It was obviously a bomb.
0
Reply
Female 731
Aw, aw..ah *cries*
0
Reply
Male 666
I think all dogs and cats should be destroyed. This way, many veterinary resources can be allocated to humans, and there would be overall less disease and parasites, from both more health resources available to humans and less animals carrying such diseases and parasites.

If people cared about their neighbors, the poor and the helpless, as much as they did about animals, our country would be a better place.

This is a very moral and humanitarian solution.

0
Reply
Male 455
I think the dog was already dead. Most puppies go limp when you hold them by the scruff of the neck, but this one seemed to have its eyes closed. Honestly, though, the quality was pretty low on the vid and I couldn`t make much out anyway. Whatever the case, I think the yelping was added in, and if you were really going to hear a puppy scream, it would be when it hit something. Not when it was in the air.
0
Reply
Male 10,440
Omg you people are crazy. You`d probably spontaneously combust in rage if he shot the puppy. I cant even begin to think what you`d do if he shot a human being!
0
Reply
Male 180
Omg thats friken funny but i feel sad inside for the puppy
0
Reply
Female 1,890
AND this is why im going to canada when i turn 18....
0
Reply
Female 1,890
im a sociopath but i only feel for animals for some reason.......odd....
0
Reply
Male 2,160
and this is why the US military should be more selective of their candidates...
0
Reply
Male 666
I hope McCain wins, because I would rather fight the enemy on their land than on U.S. soil, which I think the liberals don`t realize.

If you think countries like Iraq would just sit back peacefully and not bother the U.S., you are way too naive or just plain ignorant.

Bill Clinton already once affirmed Bush for going to war, so if you think this is isolated to Bush or republicans, you are also too ignorant. If you think Hillary or Obama wouldn`t have gone to war, you are too ignorant or naive. They only say things that sound good to liberal voters because they want to get elected. Everything changes once people actually become president. Especially once they learn top secret information they otherwise wouldn`t have known had they not become president.

0
Reply
Female 1,890
im sending this to the god damn us gov and getting him demoted

i hate animal cruelty this made me cry >_<
ide torture a person for hours
but i had to kill a cat fish and cryed

0
Reply
Male 9
If you think the dog was real.. It wasn`t.
Did you see it move ONCE during the whole video?
0
Reply
Male 10,440
I dont see whats so wrong with this. You pple are over reacting.
0
Reply
Male 1,882
The puppy is either fake or already dead:

There is no movement from the puppy`s body. Not while being held, not while being drawn back, and not even while jerking it to throw it.

The yelping from the puppy is quite clear and loud and does not get faint as the puppy travels away from the camera. Usually when someone adds a sound effect in post-production, they aren`t quite that retarded.

My conclusion: Throw fake puppy + add sound effects = offensive video.

The guy`s still a sicko for doing it.

0
Reply
Female 1,944
This makes me want to cry
0
Reply
Female 2,074
The puppy thing isn`t as bad as the innocents that Bush is killing. But it`s still pretty freakin` horrible. My heart gets crushed when I see people die due to Bush`s actions. What the hell can we do? Nothing, except for hoping the next person in office will clean things up a little. That`s all we can hope for. And now that I read today that McCain is being endorsed by Bush, I hope to everything that McCain does not win. Please, I hope to everything it does not happen.
0
Reply
Female 41
So...because people are dying in the Iraq war I`m not allowed to get mad about this? Nobody said an innocent puppy dying is more important than an innocent person dying so why does this keep getting brought up. I get it YOU don`t care but please don`t try to imply I`m only allowed to care a certain amount about certain things. Innocent people die all the time and it sucks. If somebody posted a video of that (PLEASE Don`t) I would be very pissed as well. This video however is about a puppy being killed (Fake, Already dead, whatever) so it makes sense for people to talk about what they saw and how they feel. So to this Jack ass in the video....F*%#k You!!!!
0
Reply
Female 2,074
LOL this is something his sister Kathleen wrote about him in the school paper, I presume...

http://my.highschooljournalism.org/wa/mo...

0
Reply
Female 2,074
Oh, wow, Look what I found....look at what his sister `supposedly` wrote....

Dont know if it`s fake or not...hmm..

http://reddit.com/info/6aq4l/comments/

0
Reply
Female 2,074
Nevermind. I did mis-read it...but still...wow. I would seriously feel threatened, for myself and my family, over something like this...

Fake or not.

0
Reply
Female 2,074
I think this is his sister`s or a sister`s friend Bebo space...but it`s funny, I think in the middle of the page, there is a comment from David Motari...telling his sister or the friend to get out of the US now...LOL.

Odd.

I could be mis-reading it, still interesting..

http://www.bebo.com/Profile.jsp?MemberId...

0
Reply
Male 1,455
I honestly don`t care. I find it amusing that many Americans don`t give a toss about prisoners being abused in Guantanamo Bay, but as soon as a dog gets killed they get up in arms. Some people here need a priority check.
0
Reply
Male 21
ah, that made my soul feel good, wait. what soul?
0
Reply
Male 666
^ I mean the anti-bacterial nature of soaps. Soap made from vegetable oils still kill animals.
0
Reply
Female 9
Why the hell is this posted? What enjoyment does a sane person get out of this?

It disgusts me.

0
Reply
Male 666
Ajikan is absolutely correct. There`s a definite double standard when it comes to attribution to value of life to animals. If you think dogs or cats are so valuable, then you shouldn`t take any antibiotics or use soap, because every time you do, you are killing millions of animals.

Animals are asses. They deserve to die just as much as humans.

0
Reply
Female 2,074
Oh, and two girls and one cup is NOT okay. I`ve never watched it. Never will. But it`s definitely NOT okay.
0
Reply
Female 507
Do flying puppies sound like that?
0
Reply
Female 831
I hope it`s fake. Meanwhile, drat the troops.
0
Reply
Male 1,526
really. most people here are just plain strange.
care more about an animal, than human lives.
granted humans die all the time, but so does dogs, heck, im sure even this secon a bag of puppies are drowning in a bag somewhere, and a bunch of cats are skinned alive in asia for older ladies wanting furr coats.
and its a bit hypocritical to say all life is equal. would you save the flies and mice from your burning house ?
When it comes down to it, would you risk your life for a snail or a racoon. if yes, your insane.
Animals are not innocent, they kill eachother and behave like asses just as much as humans do.
If they could they would probably threat us worse than we treat them.
0
Reply
Female 831
oh my god

i`m going to die.

0
Reply
Male 666
Soldier kill dogs in Iraq all the time. No big deal. It`s necessary to keep disease away and to keep the dogs from getting attached to them and giving away their position in the future. They also kill them to keep the dogs from eating their food when the soldiers aren`t watching.

Their real crime is not eating the puppy. What a waste of meat. If it was properly cooked, whatever disease in the meat would be cooked to death anyways. There are hungry people dying in Iraq, and the soldiers just waste such good food.

The puppy`s sounds defy the law of physics, namely the Doppler Effect. This is a fake. The marines who did this are probably laughing their ass off over people`s reactions. They are trolls.

0
Reply
Male 23
yoimmylene: how is eating crap not harmful to a human? i`m sure that those girls didn`t wake up and want to do that. i`m sure that the person who paid them to do it had a little influence in that.
0
Reply
Male 315
this has to be bullpoo, watch it again but be careful. When he pulls his arm back to throw it he definatly switched the puppy. He does it off camara, with a deliberate motion. Sleight of hand for the win.
0
Reply
Female 4
regardless of whether it`s dead or not, abusing the corpse of anything is terrible. So these guys kill iraqi`s in war, what`s the point and the comparison with the puppy?
You don`t excuse bad behavior with more bad behavior
0
Reply
Male 134
Ya, not photoshopped, this is big news, facebook groups and everything
0
Reply
Female 2,064
WRONGonRED: 2girls1cup wasn`t hurting anyone or anything.
0
Reply
Female 2,064
I`m gonna kill him. I am SO gonna kill him. Hand me a gun.
0
Reply
Male 23
People are idiots. How in the world can people get so angry over this? Tossing puppies is bad but somehow 2girls1cup is okay??! I was really hoping that this was gonna start a new YouTube fad of tossing puppies too. Oh well.
0
Reply
Male 57
ya dainty, we are all flesh and blood and hair, and nothing more
0
Reply
Male 274
its real and IAB is a bad website to get news at
0
Reply
Male 48
Couldn`t the puppy already be dead, and they just added a yelping noise?
0
Reply
Male 468
i dont thing the dog was real it didnt look like it was moving and they could have faked the noise but it is still creul >-(
0
Reply
Male 179
Hahaha, he defiantly beat my record.


I once threw a Pomeranian out of a moving car, only got 30 feet...

0
Reply
Female 2,074
Phantom7, yes life is cruel. I know that all too well. The lives and blood that have been wasted here and abroad....it`s a horrible thing. I hate the President. I hate the government. I hate the war. I worked in a place where all day I saw military men and woman of all branches burned, raw and very, very scarred. These people did not deserve this. These people were sent on a basis of lies and deception. What can you tell their parents? They died/were burned/became severely handicap...serving their country? Or they were simply tools of Bush for him to gain his own personal agendas? This war is a f.cking JOKE. Bush has lied. But what the hell can we do? Nothing! The only thing is hope for a change. We, supposedly, are voice in goverment, but it is NOT true. The govermnent rules itself. Our votes barely count. Yea, life is cruel, I feel bad for the needless deaths..but what the hell can we do? It`s f.cking horrible. It`s beyond terrible. It`s disgusting....
0
Reply
Female 29
"snoopdawgg: come on people they are people dying in iraq and nobody is this furious for that
so now a puppy is dead, the whole world is made"

fu** you... maybe if you were a real american then you would appreciate the values of our american lives. (not directed towards any others, just to this dumbass). yeah people are dying in Iraq, but that`s not our fault, they have the courage and the drive to want to go and fight for our country and i respect that 110%, but this was disgustingly wrong for them to do; or even the person who may have photoshopped it.

0
Reply
Female 2,074
I never thought too much about having a pet, until I got my kitten recently. She almost died, and is still in the hospital...it`s been over a week. We have even considered pet insurace. We love her so much now! A little life like that is so precious, and to demean their existence just because we think we are superior is wrong. That puppy was a complete innocent in this horrible war. That man is, was, and will always be a disgrace. He is definitely without soul and not a human in my eyes.
Animals are capable of love and feelings. Yes, they do feel pain. Have you ever looked into a dog`s eyes and felt it completely trusted you? How do you feel if a baby kitten jumps on your lap and gets comfy and begins to purr so sweetly? These are precious little things animals do, especially domestic ones that become a part of the family.
Now that I know how beautiful and enriching a pet can be in one`s life and family, it makes the video even more enraging.
0
Reply
Male 57
it is just an animal, put your panties back on people!
0
Reply
Male 453
DO NOT WANT!
0
Reply
Male 7,933
Its fake. If you look at the dog its not a real dog.
0
Reply
Female 1,002
This is almost like the cat burning video...except I like dogs more so I found this a lot sadder.
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO, DOGGYYYYYY!!! :(
I so hope that this is fake...PLEEEEEASE be a fake
0
Reply
Female 82
I seriously hope they get their f*cking heads blown off. Ignorant a**holes
0
Reply
Male 133
That is terrible. Some people piss me off. If it is real, I hope those soldiers get punished BIG TIME.
0
Reply
Male 416
WHERE IS YOUR DOG NOW?
0
Reply
Male 1,378
non-nice individual
0
Reply
Female 986
dot dot dot

Well, I told someone the fastest way to get onto my despicable persons list was to hurt a puppy... so yeah... there he goes. Right at the top with my most hated figures.

0
Reply
Female 2,074
Not funny. Very sad. I hate most young military men and women. The way they act is repulsive. I truly respect the good men and women out there who are in for the right causes and who have good hearts. Otherwise, men like this aren`t true Marines. They never are, and never will be.
0
Reply
Male 40
you need there to be a photo to use photoshop.
0
Reply
Male 7,933
That is fake, I`ve thrown puppies a bunch of times and they dont make that noise
0
Reply
Male 199
Fake. Obviously.
0
Reply
Male 944
roduku im sorry...that is false...
0
Reply
Male 944
one more
0
Reply
Male 459
would have been funnier if it was a cat
0
Reply
Male 957
This is a bad thing no doubt but worse things happen and have happened. I just think liberals are going to use this to tar the soldiers and this country because of the acts of one. Fine if its on the internet but the tv shouldn`t have published it.

I am simply taking the long view about this; where does it end? When will the condemnation stop? It won`t, unless we put our heads in the sand and refuse to expose ourselves to this garbage.

If the long line of condemnation does not stop due to these long line of incidents, I will be blamed for something by the Blame America First people! I will not be happy about that and the only logical thing to do is to blame this all on liberals. To Hell with the puppy, This nation and its soldiers are more important!

0
Reply
Female 345
Everyone who says that screech doesn`t fade, IT`S IN A GULLY! Anyone ever heard of an echo?
0
Reply
Female 345
People are getting so up in arms about how this incident is overshadowing soldiers dying in Iraq and how horrible it is that people care more for animals than people. That`s bullpoo. People can fight back. If this is real that puppy never had a chance.
I also believe that ALL of the men present should be held responsible.
0
Reply
Male 944
it really is just a dog, and MANY people r dying in the war, we cant stop and say..."Awww nooo they died" for those people, yet we have time to do that for a dog? it really does not matter. yes yes it is cruel but life is cruel...i kinda find this clip funny, but thats only because im a emo jackass who has no real feelings but HEY im happy!...ok no im not happy but i do enjoy cake
0
Reply
Male 1,111
It`s not real plain and simple (unless napolean420 is right)

When he lowers the dog to his side before he throws it he would have switched it out for anything that looks similar and has weight then added in the sounds. Soldiers have been making videos for fun the whole time they`ve been over there.

0
Reply
Male 50
My army buddy said they are required to kill all dogs they come across due to rabies.
0
Reply
Male 4,012
They didn`t show a video of someone being shot dead. I`m sure if they showed such a video there`d be just an uproar of not a stronger one.
0
Reply
Male 713
US Marines can be jerks, according to my experiences and this video
0
Reply
Male 189
thank you mal_BB, someone with a bit of perspective

I`m not saying that what they`ve done is right, real or not, but cmon people look at an important issue at least rather than making 100 comments about a real/unreal dog. Man I hate modern society

0
Reply
Male 1,003
you people are such whiny little p*ssies. it`s a freaking dog? come on. i used to kick birds when i was 6 or 7. it was funny... that dog was ugly, too.. i hope he died.
0
Reply
Male 2,306
I have had over 8 dogs, and none of them were paralyzed from getting grabbed by the scruff. They did relax a bit, but they squirm around.
0
Reply
Male 106
Puppy was alive they go into trances when you pick them up from the back of the neck anyone who has taken care of a puppy knows that. Don`t let the talking heads confusse you this is wrong, very wrong and he should be prosicuted by the full extent of law.
0
Reply
Male 2,306
dead dog
0
Reply
Male 1,231
over 81,000 innocent civvilians have died throughout the Iraq war...and people are up set about a puppy???
0
Reply
Male 516
@everybody who says that this puppy is nothing compared to the people who are being killed:

You are right. But nobody is questioning that it is wrong to kill people. In fact, nobody is talking about that. What does it have to do with this inhumane act?

0
Reply
Male 189
it makes me laugh at how much the majority of you are hypocrites
0
Reply
Male 944
Pyre me too! rock on!!!
0
Reply
Male 449
I must be a sick sadistic freak. I actually enjoyed that a little
0
Reply
Male 896
Also, there was a video of a dog setting off a bomb. Go army!
0
Reply
Male 1
Don`t get me wrong, this is cruel and uncalled for, but... We train them to be killers and then are surprised that there might be some unwanted side effects? Duh? It should be the military`s responsibility to attempt to rehabilitate this boy.
0
Reply
Male 896
OH! I saw this on /b/ like a week ago!
0
Reply
Female 25
thats f**king horrible. That man does not deserve to say he is a marine. The few the proud, do not kill for fun. Defending this nation should be of the highest Honor to you and your fellow citizens, and if he gets off on throwing a puppy over a cliff?I agree he should be(and probably will be) a target of some sort of hate crime as he has done for an innocent animal. This is truelly a disgrace to the American people, for the few and the proud, and I agree, he will pay for what he has done. Watch, next thing you know, I`ll be seeing this on the 6 oclock news when the fu*ker gets the sh*t beat out of him for doing this. Being a Marine, I would F*CK this guy up myself. Dirty rotten son of a bi*ch. I`f like to see the look aon his face if I threw his F*CKING KID off a cliff. Or his wife(if he has one, I feel for her too) This is a horrible post.
0
Reply
Female 62
gosh.....I can`t really find the words. same as Lauraly. And I think the life of this particular man is worth less then the puppy`s. For me he is NOT human anyway
0
Reply
Male 196
that puppy had some nice flight.
0
Reply
Male 695
This video is proof that marines are evil. I mean, they threw a puppy off a cliff! Next thing you know, there`s video`s on Youtube of them eating babies.
0
Reply
Male 129
This is probably real - looks very believable and i can`t think of any sane reason for putting in time to make this sick video to lower marine moral (but then again i was fooled by the angry German kid).

How did this come about? - you can hear dogs barking in the background and the area looks run down. Maybe the dog and puppy owners couldn`t feed them and asked the soldiers to dispose of them. And these naive soldiers thought it would be "fun" to record the disposal, without thinking about the consequences if it were revealed.

0
Reply
Male 23
oh....my......gosh! that poor puppy, how could they do such a thing? :(
0
Reply
Male 382
I would actually be willing to pay to get a hitman out on him
Note* If a hitman ACTUALLY is called out to kill him, it wasn`t me
0
Reply
Female 691
oh my fu.cking god. my friend was telling me about this.
if this is real, and ever meet this man, i swear on my left kidney i will beat him pooless.
0
Reply
Male 151
what a disgusting human being, i sincerely hope he dies a slow painful death due to loss of blood in Iraq
0
Reply
Female 368
I hate that guy...I hope he gets shot or blown up. there was NO need to do that...freakin sick a$$hole.
0
Reply
Female 2,258
Dainty, I wholeheartedly agree with you. Animals deserve just as much respect as humans do, if not more due to the fact that they aren`t evil hate machines.
I`m not a vegetarian, but that is because I believe in the circle of life. I do however choose to eat organic and free-range.
0
Reply
Male 415
It doesn`t look fake, the dog doesn`t seem to be dead. A dead animal doesn`t tend to keep its hindlegs up that much. Whether or not they substituted the dog with something else before tossing, that`s something else.

But I doubt it.

A serious lack of empathy, I don`t know if the guy would do anything different if it was a baby he were holding.

0
Reply
Female 2
Its true. They got apuppy and chucked it. :(
0
Reply
Female 145
why would they make this video fake? why would they add in fake puppy noises? stupid
0
Reply
Female 2
This is not photoshopped. Its on skynews. You sick people who watched it.
0
Reply
Male 1,526
every life is not worth the same.
i eat meat, kill flies aso.
but this was kinda unessesary.
0
Reply
Male 1,265
Anybody that finds this funny is mentally ill. No argument.
0
Reply
Male 944
@843...maybe he got attacked by a tiger or somethin!? =X
0
Reply
Male 431
exactly why we shouldnt be over there...too many marines are comin back all fawcked up
0
Reply
Male 944
5577 your right but i enjoy being so =)
and @ isuckatskool..."dog would struggle to get away." not by the way it was held
0
Reply
Male 550
His Bebo account was removed.
His brother and sister`s MySpace accounts were removed.
His mother`s real estate listing was removed.
His phone line was disconnected.
Since none of his family seems to deny this, I get the feeling that guy has had serious animal issues in the past.
0
Reply
Male 518
"i would so do that, cats rock dogs suck" - Phantom7

Neither of them suck, you`re just a dick.

0
Reply
Male 72
two things i think its edited cause the dog breed cant be found in iraq and the dog would struggle to get away. but even still its wrong imgoing to be a medic there if he gets shot im leaving
0
Reply
Female 331
It`s not a matter if Americans care more about people dying or a puppy dying. There are better ways to prove it than to fling an innocent puppy. And if you can so much as lay a finger on that cute little fella without crying....you`re a PSYCHOPATH. Send him home to a psych ward, U.S.!
0
Reply
Male 547
Bascally real, or not, this gives a horrible impression of US Marienes, also if you listen to his comment,, oops I tripped right before he threw it, he will go on to commit these acts on iraq civilians, we will prob find out that later that day he raped a 11 year old girl..
0
Reply
Female 472
Ok, this was just disgusting. Absolutely disgusting. It says on his Bebo profile that hes not afraid of anything, 10 dollars says thats changed since this video came out.
I dont know how many of you have held a puppy or kitten by thier scruff, but when you do the animal is virtually immobilized. Its because thats how the mama dog or cat holds the baby firmly by that scruff.
Im not one to wish bad on people, but this guy is a real peice of work. Just a bit of trivia, did you know that serial killers start off doing things like this? Yes. That might be what makes him such an accomplished soldier.
As disgusting as this video is, I think it was good that it was posted. Raise awareness for things like this.
0
Reply
Male 944
i would so do that, cats rock dogs suck
0
Reply
Male 54
I don`t think its for real but even so, its a weird and unfunny thing to do.
0
Reply
Male 518
Why? What`s the point?

I`d never think to say this but I hope these two pricks get shot.

0
Reply
Male 205
Male 239
its definately real their filing a law suit againts him now
0
Reply
Female 781
A kid in my English class was telling me about this, but I hoped it wasn`t real...

Needless to say, I will not be watching this video and I think it`s disgusting that you posted it.

0
Reply
Female 1,395
well im definitely not watching this.
0
Reply
Male 189
Devi thats just stupid

Isn`t he in Haawii now neway?

0
Reply
Female 1,496
David`s address and phone number.

David Mortari
24419 Florence Acres Rd
Monroe, WA 98272-9662
(360) 794-7191

0
Reply
Male 724
...;-;
0
Reply
Female 175
i wqould shove that idiot off the side of an airplane without a parachute.
0
Reply
Male 550
Actually, the sound did fade half a second before the thud, hence the reason people can`t seem to determine if it`s real or a hoax.

http://www.snopes.com/photos/military/th...

They pointed out that the sound of the yelp seems to be too clear for a camcorder or a camera phone that they seem to be using.

0
Reply
Male 91
I WILL MAKE THEM BUUUURN!!!!!!!
0
Reply
Male 254
843

I do believe he did throw a puppy off the cliff but the PUPPY WAS DEAD. The sound didn`t fade so thats fake, its just his idea of a joke, sicko.

0
Reply
Male 550
Upon watching the video a second time, I noticed two things:
1) The sound sounds authentic. I don`t have much experience hearing puppies` yelps, but the thud at the end was the perfect touch if it was fake.
2) The soldier`s hand moved out of frame for a moment before tossing the puppy. Substitution effect, much?
0
Reply
Female 55
that was very hard to watch
0
Reply
Female 263
I cant bring myself to watch it. poo like that stays with me for days :( Theres some F-ing retards in this world thats for sure.
0
Reply
Male 189
n03113 if thats directed at me then thats not what i`m implying.

I`m talking about the thousands of dead Iraqi civilians that are killed everyday in equally cruel ways.

0
Reply
Female 195
Even if it is fake, or the puppy was dead, I still think the video is in bad taste. What`s funny about throwing a puppy?

If anything, it just gives bored idiots more ideas...

0
Reply
Male 199
I don`t like (also scared of) dogs, but that is just too mean.
0
Reply
Male 61
thats surely not real!
if it was then its pretty damn sick
0
Reply
Female 228
i never thought id say this but i hope a durka shoots him.
0
Reply
Male 4,546
^A civilian`s job is...

Nice justification, but utterly lacking in one small detail.

0
Reply
Female 5
The differences between a puppy and soldiers dying in Iraq:

Men and women who join the military do so of their own free will.

A puppy is at the will of it`s owner or individual who is larger than it.

A soldier`s job is to serve our country, that comes with great KNOWN risk.

A puppy`s job is to bring joy to our lives, that comes with the hope of love and care in return.

A soldier is an adult who can make choices, they can take care of themselves when sick, during injury, or prevent bad things from happening to them by taking caution.

A puppy is young, defenseless, and cannot make choices like that of an adult human. They cannot fight back often times, due to age and general limitations as it is an animal.

How can anyone try to compare compassion for a poor innocent puppy, flung to it`s death in outright cruelty to a soldier injured or killed in Iraq? There are casualties in any war... both military and civilian... But this was a puppy, and it makes me sick.

0
Reply
Male 189
The dog got pwned worse than the pimp!!
0
Reply
Male 27
man I love dogs, that sucks
0
Reply
Male 480
and i mean the fading of the screech
0
Reply
Male 480
the screech could be the low quality sound from the cellphone
0
Reply
Male 480
not clearly THE DOG IS DEAD
it could be dead already and i like the word COULD

also: all you people wanting to kill this guy and what not, you guys crack me up. All you senseless people are just like that soldier in the video. Ridiculus.

and how do you know that puppy aint as mean as them (joking lol)

0
Reply
Male 254
843

Thankyou, someone who agrees wit me.

0
Reply
Male 550
I kept thinking that the dog is an inanimate object. It appears lifeless. Not to mention the screech at the end doesn`t match its increasing distance.
0
Reply
Male 254
Ok cause noone is going to the link i posted ill just tell you:

1. Does it look like the puppy is alive in the first place?

2. Does the screach from the dog fade out as it gets further away?

3. Does the scream sound added in, do you think it would be the screach from that dog?


Yes i do think it is a messed up video but clearly the dog is dead in the first place.

0
Reply
Male 6
OMG such an apt metaphor for the presence of the United States in Iraq!
0
Reply
Male 189
From The Times, "If David Motari is the puppy killer, he is undoubtedly a sociopath who does not feel remorse or shame," wrote Mike on the Crime and Federalism weblog.

Part of the guys job description is to kill people surely?!? If we fills himself with remorse then he wouldn`t last very long.

I also find it interesting that people are so horrifed by a puppy dying but not thousands of members of the Iraq public being killed

0
Reply
Male 4,012
Some people get turned on in the strangest ways.

Poor puppy btw. it`s these times that I wish someone would throw the guy off the cliff.

0
Reply
Male 3,301
Well maybe it was a TERRORIST dog! You never know... :-/

This reminds me of that one video a while back of some other solders shooting an innocent dog for kicks.

0
Reply
Female 4
WTF why put CRAP like that on here?!?!?! Thats low.....Wouldnt thought i would see S*H*I*T like that on this site
0
Reply
Male 656
^^ i agree with engrul and all the people that said it before her^^

but im 98.7 percennts sure hat is was fake

0
Reply
Male 254
Female 401
this guy had a choice to be in the marines (for all of the people who are defending them) the puppy didnt have a choice so stfu. sickening humans pssht
0
Reply
Male 300
I want to use my recently learned knowledge of disarming that guy`s gun and shoot him in the fricken skull. . .how terrible it is to do such an inhumane act. . .even though a human life is worth more, that does not give him the right to commit such a thing
0
Reply
Female 267
this is fcking sick
it`s everywhere
and I hate it

and to snoopdawgg:
because its a damn PUPPY, not only is it a baby but its an innocent dog. this wasnt done because they had to, or they were ordered to, but because that was their sick minded idea of fun.

0
Reply
Female 469
Saw this on the news. And about caring for the puppy more than the soldiers: They chose to be there and they knew the risks. That poor thing didn`t.
0
Reply
Male 2,172
I think that the dog was a north-american mutt... what were they doing with a dog like that in the desert in the first place?

I seriously hope that it a good fake... a lot of news media have the story now and are waiting for a confession from the soldier.

David Motari is the name of the soldier according to this news article.

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/iraq/article3481977.ece

0
Reply
Female 178
Sick.
0
Reply
Male 777
To snoopdawgg:

That`s because people suck and puppies are awesome.

0
Reply
Male 777
Seriously, if I ever meet that guy (and I might, as he`s supposed to live in the same basic area) I`m going to walk right up to him and kick him in the nuts.
0
Reply
Female 744
INTERNET HAET MACHINE!
0
Reply
Male 480
mad*
0
Reply
Male 480
come on people they are people dying in iraq and nobody is this furious for that

so now a puppy is dead, the whole world is made

0
Reply
Male 3,301
I dont know, this still sounds kinda fake to me. The squealing of the dog kinda sounds fake or added in to me.
0
Reply
Male 2,113