School Guards Break Child`s Arm For Dropping Cake

Submitted by: Snoogans 9 years ago
http://www.myfoxla.com/myfox/pages/Home/Detail;jsessionid=81401CAEF2EC7F5196628A8E31DC23D3?contentId=4473580&version=2&locale=EN-US&layoutCode=VSTY&pageId=1.1.1&sflg=1

How is she supposed to clean up her mess with a broken arm?
There are 118 comments:
Female 532
Yeah...

Um, to all those saying she`s milking it: if a person who had NO RIGHT TO TOUCH YOU AT ALL had broken your arm for simply having a little attitude and not picking up a piece of cake correctly, wouldn`t you want everybody to know about it? I would!

Security guards at my school weren`t even allowed to break up fights unless they saw blood or weapons. And they certainly weren`t allowed to do anything more than search the occasional locker or drive around in their little golf-carts....

yeah, there`s more to this back there, somehwere, behind the media noise... But I bet it won`t make much of a difference. The guy can`t have a single good reason for breaking bones.

0
Reply
Female 75
drat the police.

what the drat is up with them going ballistic all the sudden? actually, more likely that it`s been happening for years and years but only now do we have the technology to record and show evidence of it to everyone.

0
Reply
Female 205
That guy BETTER GET SUED/ARRESTED.
0
Reply
Male 1,455
A security guard is not a law enforcement agent. Shoot her? That would be murder, folks.
0
Reply
Male 221
I dunno I think there might be more than what they said. But o well
0
Reply
Male 22
He should of used his gun, was he not trained correctly? As everyone said there is probably more to the story, hopefully we will find out more someday.
0
Reply
Male 1,141
who the heck has security guards at their school? lol
0
Reply
Male 393
Shoot her. that is all.
0
Reply
Male 4,246
MechBFP, do NOT even start that. Seriously.
0
Reply
Male 813
Why would I not be surprised if this was 100% of the truth? Oh I know because it happened in the US where common sense is against the law.
0
Reply
Male 341
Eh, the first thing that came up to my mind was "Don`t cry over spilled milk"
0
Reply
Male 91
Did anyone notice like %80 of the kids who scream "Z0MG-Teh Razism!!" all the time are under seventeen? Listen up kiddies, stop buying everything the TV shoves in your face. You have no idea what this guard must put up with everyday, or if this girl causes him trouble all the time. Also, lay off the whole "racism" thing, I get called "cracka" all the time, but if I were to say the "N" word, OH NOES TEH RAZISM!! Double Standard FTW. Everyone grow up.
0
Reply
Male 24
:O or maybe, the cop/what ever he is,
thought the cake has some chemicals in it which
when it touches dirty floor tiles it got 30 seconds til it go boom! so the cop tells her to clean it up so she does but not all the way so the world is doomed so the cop thinks to himself
"hey! she dooms us all,ima break her wrist and go crazy on everybody else! good idea, me!"
and did just that! it may sound far fetch and if u got to were i am right now then good for you,
i know pronounce that you don`t have ADD/ADHD
:) arnt u happy that i went on this long?

572 charaters

0
Reply
Male 358
"BITCH YOU GON` WISH YOU DID NOT DROP THAT CAKE." /manhandle.
0
Reply
Female 158
i`m sure there leaving alot of details out. but thats still messed up.
0
Reply
Male 1,404
I do not care if this child was voted the b_itch of the year the security guard had no legal standing to use force to restrain this victim. His job is to observe and report. A security guard is not a law enforcement agent and has no privileges beyond a normal citizen. This should be a wake up call to the community the schools community with demand that the security staff as well as the principle, the person in charge, be terminated.
0
Reply
Male 200
maybe the guard thought that the cake was a weapon... maybe he`s diabetic and she offered him the cake?
or my favourite "LOOK OUT! SHE`S GOT CAKE!" *breaks her arm* You stupid girl you could have killed us!
But why did the news reporter keep talking over what the girl and her mother was saying?
0
Reply
Male 107
The cop is a racist son of a B17CH!
0
Reply
Male 1,371
to the guy who supposedly goes to this school, I don`t think "at worst" you would get a detention for dropping cake, wouldn`t you just like clean it up and move on ._.

seriously there has GOT to be some conspiracy involving this, why would she get expelled, and what`s going on with spectators getting in trouble?

0
Reply
Male 307
The kid who took a picture of this incident got arrested, therefore by that logic all news reporters should be sentenced to death for doing their jobs,,|,, >__<,,|,,
0
Reply
Male 35
Wow at my school the police call it "Crime ridge" ( pine ridge is the name BTW) because we have wanna be thugs and poo jumping the rent-a-cops,bringing guns to the football games, gang fights and drugs but none of that poo makes news. a girl dropping cake does and shes prolly milking it like most people do. messed up.
0
Reply
Male 396
someone has to find out wat happens when and if this goes to courts
0
Reply
Female 23
Wow, I`m suprised this got on here.
I go to that school.

Something they forgot to mention was that the kids recording/taking pictures got tackled to the ground so they could try and take their phones away, which to me, is a sure sign that they were very well aware that they were doing something wrong.

The girl who got her wrist broken ended up getting expelled. Over cake. F--kin ridiculous, right?

Poor dear, I feel bad for her. She`s a pretty nice kid; I don`t know her personally, but she was pretty okay compared to some of the other kids that go to our school.

But honestly, this is so ridiculous. I bet that if at some other school, someone dropped cake, the worst that would happen to them is detention or after school work, or something of the sort. A broken wrist and getting arrested over cake is just pointlessly stupid.

0
Reply
Female 673
Well, I wanna see the other side of the story, but even if the girl was partly in the wrong, I still think the guard was also in the wrong. If ANY of the facts are REMOTELY true.

And I agree with sprink about implying. It`s not like it`s an incredibally unique idea, hearing all sides of the story first. It`s just common sense, really. The fact that one other person had the same idea as you isn`t really all that unusual.

0
Reply
Male 290
she didn`t get tazed repetitively, that would have made this crazy story complete.

lol and this is exactly like HL2, only with fat white bald racist cops as the combine.

0
Reply
Female 876
Why didn`t any of the kids around her do anything? They just watched. Maybe she did something the video doesn`t show us?

It`d be nice to know more about what happened..

0
Reply
Male 59
Wow. And to the person who said it reminded them of Half-Life 2, exactly. When I play that game again on my 360 when Orange Box comes out, I swear I`m going to yell out "Don`t tase me, bro!" everytime one of those guys approaches me at the beginning.
0
Reply
Male 876
Stupid security gaurd arrests her for dropping cake? WTF?
0
Reply
Male 358
I don`t care what she did! Breaking an arm is not something you do to a student unless they have a weapon! The story must be biased but still...
0
Reply
Male 1,386
hmm... a whole bunch of PWN for everyone :D. whats up with all of them getting arrested?
0
Reply
Male 1,220
^^ unless its *shudder* ice cream cake.... that doesn`t count
0
Reply
Male 1,220
bitch deserved it.... cake is too sacred to be dropped. even on accident.
0
Reply
Male 352
I would be hesitant to pass judgment on this until I have heard the other side of the story.
0
Reply
Male 393
^^^ see implying. EVERYBODY wants to hear the other side of the story. Is ImNoGod copying you now? No, of course he isn`t you tw*t.
0
Reply
Male 195
idk wat to think, i bet theres more to it though
0
Reply
Male 1,149
I want to hear both sides of the story. I want to know what really happened.
0
Reply
Male 393
^^^ implying, You are another of the complete idiots on here. Do you really think you have some sort of copyright on a sentence? It`s not even the same for christ sake, just portraying the same sentiment. What a pratt you are. And to actually put a post up pointing it out! Jesus.......
0
Reply
Male 20
wtf starshine? you just totally copied the first sentence of my post there-

starshine: i`d like to hear the other side of the story before i pass judgement on that part of the US.

me: I would be hesitant to pass judgment on this until I have heard the other side of the story.

BTW:

0
Reply
Male 393
^^^ well said bigfatpig, he should have broke her other arm as well.
0
Reply
Male 352
Starshine `bigfatpig, shut the drat up. you don`t make sense and you are a waste of oxygen and skin - more than your fair share, it sounds like.`

I make a lot more sense than you, little Miss ` i`d like to hear the other side of the story before i pass judgement on that - aren`t i all grown up`. At least i have an opinion and am not afraid to say exactly what i think, unlike you namby pamby fence sitters. Christ, people like you are so spineless it makes me puke. Come back when you are older and actually have something to say.

0
Reply
Female 582
a security guard is supposed to protect people. They arn`t custodial nazis. It doesn`t matter if she refused to pick up the cake. That`s not his job to tell her to do so, and it certainly didn`t justify his racism. I hope he gets destroyed by the system.
0
Reply
Female 706
bigfatpig, shut the drat up. you don`t make sense and you are a waste of oxygen and skin - more than your fair share, it sounds like.

i`d like to hear the other side of the story before i pass judgement on that part of the US. it doesn`t matter; i`m getting the hell out of this country anyway. i feel sorry for the girl though - i`ve broken my wrist before, and it friggin HURTS!

0
Reply
Male 1,825
thats genuis, let a dirty skinhead become a cop around children. ive always hated rent a cops. they are total douchebags
0
Reply
Male 5
He hit her, BECAUSE YOU ARE HEADCRAB ZOMBIE
0
Reply
Male 352
He should have shot her as well.
0
Reply
Male 1,455
"Why can this only happen here in America? Why do we have so many comments (not just on this video) of "Only in America." or "Boy you Americans are dumb/stupid/retarded/add your own " Are we to believe that nothing like this happens anywhere else but here??
We have, as some others said, become to quick to jump on the racial band wagon. We do not know what happened for sure in this situation to truly judge for or against any one party. I do agree however that the guard did use excessive force, but as some of you have said, why is the sling on the other arm and not the one we see twisted behind her back. I would like to know more about this case. Does anyone have anymore info?"

There`s a very good reason. In the US, people seem to defend the police in these sorts of situations (look at the kid who got tasered), whereas in Europe the people are smart enough to wake up and say UH OH POLICE STATE HERE WE COME.

0
Reply
Male 20
a juicy scandal.

(stupid character cap)

0
Reply
Male 343
f americans!
jk but seriously...
that`s messed up,.....................................................................
0
Reply
Male 20
I would be hesitant to pass judgment on this until I have heard the other side of the story. So far it seems extremely biased and I think the media is trying to suck it dry with all the juicy goodness of a "corrupt" school system a "racist" guard and an "innocent" black girl.

Being arrested for simply not picking up cake screams BS to me. Maybe this is some ghetto school where all the students carry weapons around. Maybe some weapons were pulled and a riot broke out (other students were arrested). WHO KNOWS? Three seconds of video is hardly evidence. And getting a broken wrist seems like a likely consequence of trying to fight back against the guards and it hardly deserves the title of "beating."

BUT LET ME BE CLEAR: I am not saying that the girl is guilty, that the guards are innocent, or that this is justified in any way. I just hate seeing everybody scream bloody murder when the media jumps on a story like this and transforms it into

0
Reply
Male 418
Can you smell it? It smells like.. AL SHARPTONNNNNNN
0
Reply
Male 1,371
so she dropped a piece of cake and some dumbsh*t broke her arm? wtf o_O

this story seems too weird to be racism but i wouldn`t put it past some cops, but what exactly did she do that the cop would defend himself for doing that?

0
Reply
Male 3,619
Lynch the drating Racist powr-tripping, rent-A-cop, wannabe of an arse, but i agree with catapilrgirl, lets hear the full story b4 jumping to conclusions.

i probably wouldnt belive the school cop, nomatther what he says. :P

0
Reply
Male 4,393
wow i hate my high school :(
0
Reply
Male 233
"Is it just me or are British schools more violent than American ones seem?"

sadly, the reaction you`d get depends on who it is being "attacked", or which clique they`re in, at least where i am it would. if it was some weirdo or jerk, we`d just laugh. but if someone really nice or "cool" or something ended up like this, the body guard would get owned by 100 some odd people.

0
Reply
Male 68
"By the way, DON`T TASE HER, BRO!!!"

Lol.

0
Reply
Male 396
wow this gay
0
Reply
Male 352
^^^And it`s people like you that bore the pants of everyone.
0
Reply
Male 2
And its people like Yaas that give midwesterners a bad rep.
0
Reply
Male 2
"It`s not f*cking racist. Everyone nowadays is so quick to jump on the racist bandwagon it makes me sick. Disrespectful little sh*ts like this need a good lesson sometimes. It`s because everyones afraid to tell anyone off for anything now that society is going down the pan. She`ll think twice now next time she tries to be clever. Some of the smart little sh*ts out there need their neck breaking, let alone their arms."

You are an effing racist just like that rent-a-cop! What could she have said that was so disrespectful that could lead to her wrist getting injured.

0
Reply
Female 158
Thankfully we don`t have security guards in Britain, I feel sorry for those people that do get injured by them especially the ones they taser. If we did have those guards in England and they tried something like this, there would be a full scale riot and it would be 500 kids on one guy. Is it just me or are British schools more violent than American ones seem?
0
Reply
Male 1,228
And only in I-A-B will you find the no-life Europeans!
0
Reply
Male 46
i think the guy just wanted some cake.

when i was in 7th grade i dropped some potatoes outside....but i didnt get my arm broke over it.

0
Reply
Male 233
this reminds me of an incident in my school. a father was tasered, removed,(and i think arrested) in the main office for "assault" when he refused to leave when the office refused to call in students that were making fun of his homosexual son.

schools like these think they have every right to do what they want, and it`s not right. They think just because they make the rules, that they can get away with anything. Very rarely can you even find teachers that give a damn about a student`s opinion anymore.

and ppl wonder why dropout rates are so high...

0
Reply
Male 352
^^^ Yaas is right, get off your politically correct high horse and go back inside.
0
Reply
Female 584
And, Yaas, if that comment was your personal opinion...how incredibly selfish and racist of you.
If not, no bother.
0
Reply
Female 584
How incredibly selfish and racist of that security guard.
0
Reply
Male 91
Maybe if you had to deal with black nonsense everyday at work you`d explode to, just saying.
0
Reply
Male 1,497
racist security guard... wtf is up with america...drating police
0
Reply
Male 455
This is screwed up. We only get to see one side of the story, but I`m pretty sure breaking a 16 year old`s wrist constitutes excessive force. Besides, he wasn`t even a cop. They might as well have rodeo clowns patrolling the hallways with handcuffs.

Also off topic, but in response to roduku; mastahodisas has been plugging the same website in each comment. Can you be banned from this site from doing that?

0
Reply
Male 418
The way I see it..the girl should consider herself lucky! Diabetes and obesity is the leading problem affecting our youth and if she had eaten that cake, she would have been on the road to ruin. Instead, she got some physical exercise!
0
Reply
Male 459
I find it interesting that the mother was arrested for assault. They say the nut doesn`t fall far from the tree. I think there`s a lot more to the story.

Off topic, but for anyone interested. I`ve seen the same comment from mastahodisas in no less than four comment sections so far.

0
Reply
Female 2,220
American. Police. Drive. Me. INSANE.
0
Reply
Male 1,623
I hate law enforcers.
0
Reply
Male 9
She probably desreved that.
0
Reply
Male 64
Did you all see how ugly and nappy haired that girl is? She deserved it for being so dumb.

Besides, I never got to celebrate anything when I was in high school, and people who think they should are stupid and should be punished for having fun.

0
Reply
Female 36
Why can this only happen here in America? Why do we have so many comments (not just on this video) of "Only in America." or "Boy you Americans are dumb/stupid/retarded/add your own " Are we to believe that nothing like this happens anywhere else but here??
We have, as some others said, become to quick to jump on the racial band wagon. We do not know what happened for sure in this situation to truly judge for or against any one party. I do agree however that the guard did use excessive force, but as some of you have said, why is the sling on the other arm and not the one we see twisted behind her back. I would like to know more about this case. Does anyone have anymore info?
0
Reply
Male 352
......oh, and balls to anyone that disagrees.
0
Reply
Male 352
It`s not f*cking racist. Everyone nowadays is so quick to jump on the racist bandwagon it makes me sick. Disrespectful little sh*ts like this need a good lesson sometimes. It`s because everyones afraid to tell anyone off for anything now that society is going down the pan. She`ll think twice now next time she tries to be clever. Some of the smart little sh*ts out there need their neck breaking, let alone their arms.


So there.

0
Reply
Female 308
1)If she dropped the cake outside I can`t see why she would be expected to clean up the crumbs 2)Were they not at a school? If she dropped it inside, don`t most schools have janitors? aren`t janitors paid to clean up after accidents like that? After all if you vomited in the hall would you be expected to clean it up? No, someone would get the janitor to.
0
Reply
Male 306
omfg, that is one racist guard, lol when I read the title, I thought it was from china or some very strict country, but this is freaking racist.
0
Reply
Female 663
Yeah, I too noticed that her arm was different, but I`m guessing that there was more to the video. Either way you look at it that was excessive force. That guy had at least 70+ pounds on her. And his partner didn`t make him look any less guilty by pushing the camera away. Yeah, we had security at my school, but they`d never touch any of us like that. But then again, our security was pretty cool with everyone on campus. I remember when fights used to break out on campus and instead of breaking them up they`d stand on the sideline and take bets on who would win.
0
Reply
Male 1,254
Man I love these Europeans in here. Anytime something like this comes up it really makes me happy I live here.

What`s it like to live with blinders on?

Nevertheless, that much force wasn`t necessary. But there could have been prior incidents, perhaps with this girl, so like people have been saying I`d like to see if there is more to this story.

We need to find the nice common ground between letting kids run wild and breaking their arms. I call that middle ground...dodgeball.

0
Reply
Male 205
Only in the US...
0
Reply
Male 761
one guy from YT actualy goes to that school and he told me about that the day it happened...
0
Reply
Male 200
There is WAY more to this story than they are showing... At least I hope to God there is.

Would the story be different if the girl had pulled a weapon on the guard?

We did not see what happened just prior to the cell phone video.

BUT maybe he is an A-hole and likes to beat-up on kids. If that`s the case is butt belongs in jail..

0
Reply
Male 312
Maybe she had drugs in the cake :x
0
Reply
Male 2
wuguwa, i noticed that too. i can`t believe nobody else did. the arm that was being twisted was not the arm that was in the sling during the interview!
0
Reply
Male 814
you know how impossible it is to clean up cake properly? Icing and crumbs and all, need a mop or something
0
Reply
Male 107
Another S.O.B. abusing their power. Doesn`t surprise me.
0
Reply
Male 695
Wow...kinda reminds me of Half Life 2. PICK UP THE CAN OR MEET MY ZAPSTICK!
0
Reply
Male 123
Lol, if the guard had a taser she would get shocked endlessly.
0
Reply
Male 916
Kennybrooks, according to this story she did pick up the cake and went even back a second time to pick up the crumbs as well.
0
Reply
Male 152
okay did anybody else notice that the arm he twisted back was not the one in a sling...anyone. just curious.
0
Reply
Male 292
well i think the only real solution here would have been to shoot her, i mean yeah a little more mess to clean up but one less stupid bitch dropping cake
0
Reply
Male 36
CmdrBittles
Female, 18-29, Canada
445 Posts Tuesday, October 02, 2007 3:10:21 AM
Who cares if she didn`t clean up the f*cking cake? It`s CAKE!!

I would hate to live at your house if that is your attitude. Let someone else clean up your mess. Yeah, right. It is inconsiderate people like this that leave messes for everyone else to have to clean up.

0
Reply
Male 46
You just know they are going to milk this for as much money as possible regardless of who is guilty of what. And if all else fails just play the racist card, there you go lots of money and no need to go back to the horrible nazi school.
0
Reply
Male 298
onto the video, wow what a screwed up security guard, he is meant to be doing stuff like, stopping kids doing drugs and keeping bad people out of the school, not going all aggro cuz some girl doesnt clean up some cake off the floor, isn`t it punishment enough that she doesnt get any cake and now you are breaking her f*cking arm?
0
Reply
Male 298
wow did you see that black reporter, he got like the chickenpox randomly in the middle of the report, he started out with normal skin and then it was all drated up 20 seconds later
0
Reply
Male 4,246
This is perverse. Let`s hope more details DO come out, `cause as it stands things do not look good for Mr. Security.

By the way, DON`T TASE HER, BRO!!!

0
Reply
Female 150
ok first, why did she have to go back 3 times to clean it up? how hard is it to clean something up the first time? you KNOW she had to have attitude and second somehow i seriously doubt she had never heard the term "nappy head" before to know the guy was (so they say) being racist. something just dosen`t sit right with this one with me.
yeah he may have overreacted but you try being around smart @$$ed kids all day and see if you don`t feel like breaking their necks, nevermind wrist.

oh and a side note, as far back as junior high we had cops at all our schools year round (i started jr high in 1986)

0
Reply
Male 1,275
A)She was a smart little b*tch and got pwned or B) Some fat a** got a power trip. Then option C) A little of both.
0
Reply
Male 4,012
He needs to learn anger management. Children DO misbehave and they must be disciplined, but not by breaking their arm.
0
Reply
Female 204
can someone explain to me what the racist comment was, i`ve never heard that before...maybe because i`m not american
0
Reply
Female 299
Apparently, two girls had their wrists broken. And the freshman recording the event was tackled to the ground.
0
Reply
Female 299
So the victim and her family gets arrested for the crime that was committed against her? That makes a whole effing lot of sense...
0
Reply
Male 2,076
A white cop telling a black girl to pick up something she accidentally dropped, three times?

Even if the kid cussed the cop out, it doesn`t justify breaking the girls arm and calling her racial names. Maybe some sort of probation but not...that. Even if the story is one sided. In order for that to be justified she would have had to have been using some kind of weapon.

0
Reply
Female 1,172
Who cares if she didn`t clean up the f*cking cake? It`s CAKE!!!!!!!!!!! I don`t even know if we have schools with security guards here...I`ve never seen it.
0
Reply
Female 674
I agree with Zerocyde.
I know kids, and I know they can be disrespectful. The fact that she didn`t even make an attempt to clean up the mess to begin with and had to be told several time is an obvious sign.
0
Reply
Female 3,562
Piano, what are you gonna do, start a riot? Watch as no one joins you and you get punished too. Plus, they mention other students were arrested, so we can assume this is what happened.
0
Reply
Female 3,562
Unless she was actually posing a threat to anyone, nothing about this is even remotely justified.
0
Reply
Male 315
The guard did use a racial slur. I`d like to see the other side of the case, but if the mother was arrested as well (and obviously released) there may be something here.
I am disappointed in the "bystander syndrome" that occurred though. Why not stand up for a fellow classmate if the cause is just?
0
Reply
Male 3,255
Ohh and...

"another fat dude on a power trip-america is retarded"

Sorry, but you have to be using at least sixth grade grammar to call someone retarded, its the law. *shurg*

0
Reply
Male 3,255
Hey morons commenting so far, remember that this is only the family`s side of the story so far. I`d give a 90% chance that they are leaving some of the details out. It seems CRAZY for all this to happen just because of what the girl said happened.

BUT, if I`m wrong and their side of the story is truly accurate, then lets lynch that dratin` rent-a-cop.

All in all, wait for all the information before you toss in your opinion.

0
Reply
Male 73
another fat dude on a power trip-america is retarded
0
Reply
Male 1,364
sue the hell out of this pig
0
Reply
Female 650
Thats drated up. She`s getting beat and someone pulls out there cellphone? Well, I suppose theres not much they could of done. =/ i dont like this story much.
0
Reply
Female 8
Ech. Saw this on the news. Brutal.
0
Reply
Male 869
Link: School Guards Break Child`s Arm For Dropping Cake [Rate Link] - How is she supposed to clean up her mess with a broken arm?
0
Reply